Catastrophe Claims Supervisor

Shelter Insurance Companies•Lexington, KY
•$69,264 - $88,645

About The Position

The Catastrophe Claims Supervisor coordinates and supervises personnel handling weather-related and catastrophe claims. The role monitors and reviews claim files to ensure appropriate handling of policy provisions, company procedures, and legal obligations; assigns claims to independent adjusters and oversees claim processing; and selects, trains, and develops supervised personnel. The supervisor maintains current knowledge of policy provisions, company procedures, and state claims laws, and is assigned responsibilities for catastrophe response teams and operations. The position also supports compliance with innovation training and departmental tools. The role requires travel as needed, potentially up to 30%, and the ability to perform essential job functions with or without reasonable accommodation. The stated minimum starting pay range is $69,264–$88,645.

Requirements

  • Superior oral and written leadership and communication skills.
  • Insurance knowledge acquired through Shelter's Basic Claims Schools and successful completion of Associate of Claims coursework, or equivalent developmental training in another insurance environment, is typically required.
  • Typically requires at least three years of successful claims-adjusting experience, with superior organization, communication, and decision-making skills and thorough knowledge of claims procedures, insurance policies, and coverages.
  • Ability to comprehend and apply insurance policies, claims laws, and management reports.
  • Ability to acquire an adjuster license in states of operation, as required.
  • Must acquire and maintain an adjuster license in states of operation.
  • Ability to perform essential job functions with or without reasonable accommodation.

Nice To Haves

  • Completion of Associate in Claims coursework is preferred.
  • Thorough knowledge of insurance claims operations, specifically Shelter's policies and claims procedures, is strongly preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Coordinate and supervise personnel handling weather-related and catastrophe claims.
  • Monitor and review claim files to ensure proper handling of policy provisions, procedures, and legal obligations.
  • Assign claims to independent adjusters and oversee claim processing.
  • Select, train, and develop supervised personnel.
  • Maintain current knowledge of policy provisions, company procedures, and state laws governing claims.
  • Supervise catastrophe response teams and operations as assigned.
  • Support compliance with innovation training and departmental tools.
  • Travel as required, potentially up to 30%.

Benefits

  • Health insurance
  • Dental insurance
  • Voluntary vision and prescription drug insurance
  • Savings and profit sharing 401(k)
  • Paid time off for sick and personal leave, vacation, and holidays
  • Vitality Wellness Program
  • Dress for Your Day dress code
  • Flexible scheduling
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service