Auto Garage Claims Specialist

Universal Shield Insurance Group•Dublin, OH

About The Position

The Auto Garage Claims Specialist will maintain a claim load of litigated and non-litigated claims. This role involves investigating and verifying coverage, investigating losses by gathering all pertinent information, issuing coverage determinations, and consulting with in-house coverage counsel as appropriate. The specialist will investigate, evaluate, and adjust assigned claims in accordance with company policies, applicable laws and regulations, and within assigned authority. They will exercise independent decision-making with minimal to moderate supervision and direction on assigned claims, using knowledge of applicable codes, laws, standards, and regulations. For litigated claims, the specialist will assign defense counsel and ensure cases are handled effectively and efficiently until final resolution through settlement or judgment, collaborating with panel counsel on claims strategy and ensuring compliance with the company’s outside counsel guidelines. The role also includes preparing and presenting claim recommendations to upper management, investigating and identifying all sources of recovery and subrogation, and attending mediations, arbitrations, or trials when necessary. The specialist will work with SIU to protect the company from false or inflated claims, ensure claim files are timely documented, accurate, current, and complete, and maintain active tasks for assigned claims files with the current plan of action. Responsibilities also include responding to insureds and third parties promptly, courteously, and professionally, relaying claim status to insureds in a timely manner, and researching and resolving problems or referring them to management. The specialist will attend meetings and training as necessary, keep management and the underwriting team apprised of developments and emerging trends, and handle special projects and additional responsibilities as assigned.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s Degree required.
  • Required insurance certifications and licenses. If not licensed, must complete licensure within 60 days of employment.
  • Minimum 5-10 years of related professional experience handling auto and casualty claims.
  • Prior litigation management experience preferred.
  • Understanding of general legal concepts is required.
  • Comprehensive knowledge of insurance policies and the ability to understand complex documents is required.
  • Strong interpersonal and public relations skills.
  • Effective communication skills.
  • Solid analytical skills.
  • Ability to identify and understand coverage issues with good knowledge of exclusions and endorsements.
  • Good organizational, problem-solving, and prioritization skills.
  • Ability to use related office and computer equipment and administrative claims systems with training.

Nice To Haves

  • Prior litigation management experience preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Maintains claim load of litigated and non-litigated claims.
  • Investigates and verifies coverage; investigates losses by gathering all pertinent information; issues coverage determinations; and consults with in-house coverage counsel as appropriate.
  • Investigates, evaluates, and adjusts assigned claims in accordance with all company policies and procedures, with all applicable laws and regulations, and within assigned authority.
  • May use independent adjusters to assist in claim investigations as appropriate.
  • Exercises independent decision-making with minimal to moderate supervision and direction on assigned claims, using knowledge of applicable codes, laws, standards, and regulations.
  • For litigated claims, assigns defense counsel and ensures cases are handled effectively and efficiently until final resolution through settlement or judgment.
  • Collaborates with panel counsel on claims strategy and ensures counsel is complying with the company’s outside counsel guidelines.
  • Prepares and presents claim recommendations to upper management.
  • Investigates and identifies all sources of recovery and subrogation for assigned claims.
  • When necessary and appropriate, attends mediations, arbitrations, or trials on assigned claims.
  • Works with SIU to protect the company from false or inflated claims.
  • Ensures information in claim files is timely documented, accurate, current, and complete.
  • Maintains active tasks for assigned claims files, with the current plan of action.
  • Responds to insureds and third parties in a prompt, courteous, and professional manner.
  • Relays status of claims to insureds in a timely manner.
  • Researches and resolves problems, questions, or concerns or refers them to management as appropriate.
  • Attends meetings and training as necessary.
  • Keeps management and underwriting team apprised of developments and emerging trends.
  • Handles special projects and additional responsibilities as assigned.

Benefits

  • medical coverage with company-contributed HSA
  • dental and vision insurance
  • company-matched 401(k)
  • optional voluntary benefits
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service