Supervisor, Personal Lines Underwriting

Tower Hill Insurance Group LLC•Alachua, FL

About The Position

The Personal Lines Underwriting Supervisor oversees the daily operations of an assigned team of Personal Lines underwriters and underwriting technicians, ensuring high performance, operational efficiency, and compliance with company guidelines and underwriting standards. The position provides frontline leadership and guidance to staff while monitoring workflows, maintaining quality control, and implementing process improvements. It serves as a subject matter expert on underwriting processes and works collaboratively with department leadership to support the department’s strategic direction. Tower Hill Insurance Group seeks a professional who is interested in intellectual challenges, career advancement, personal growth, and a long-term career in the insurance industry. The company describes itself as a growing organization and offers competitive pay, benefits, and well-being programs to support employees and their families.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree required; equivalent experience may substitute for the minimum educational requirement. Equivalent experience may include five years of relevant experience.
  • At least four years of relevant auto and property and casualty work experience required.
  • Valid driver’s license required.

Nice To Haves

  • Prior supervisory experience preferred.
  • Property and casualty insurance industry designations preferred, such as Associate in Claims (AIC) or Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter (CPCU).
  • Active insurance license preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Supervise a team of underwriters and underwriting technicians, ensuring service excellence, sound risk selection, and compliance with company guidelines and authority levels.
  • Assign, prioritize, and monitor workflow to maintain efficiency, service-level standards, and timely completion of departmental tasks.
  • Provide ongoing coaching and performance feedback to support employee development and accountability.
  • Identify, recommend, and implement process improvements to increase underwriting efficiency, consistency, and cycle-time performance.
  • Participate in monthly quality assurance processes, providing insights to leadership and constructive feedback to team members.
  • Serve as a subject matter expert for complex underwriting referrals, exceptions, audits, and escalated customer or agent issues and complaints within established authority levels.
  • Maintain in-depth knowledge of regulatory requirements and market considerations for Personal Lines property and auto, and ensure underwriting practices align with applicable laws and filings.
  • Lead or support special projects, audits, and system updates affecting departmental operations.
  • Represent the organization at agent meetings, company events, and other business functions as needed.

Benefits

  • Medical insurance
  • Dental insurance
  • Vision insurance
  • Life and disability insurance
  • 401(k)
  • Health Savings Account
  • Accident, Critical Illness, and Hospital Indemnity coverage
  • Pet insurance
  • Paid time off
  • Holiday pay
  • Well-being programs
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service