Personal Lines Underwriting Manager (Hybrid)

Selective Insurance Company of America•Short Hills, NJ
•Hybrid

About The Position

Manages the Personal Lines underwriting team and Service Center operation, ensuring achievement of profit, growth, retention, service, and quality assurance goals, as well as marketing initiatives. All duties and responsibilities must be carried out in compliance with applicable legal and regulatory requirements. The role oversees underwriting performance and staff expertise, develops strategic initiatives aligned with Corporate Personal Lines SBU objectives, and advises internal and external partners on complex underwriting issues. It also supports expense management, pricing and product strategies, staff training, quality assurance, customer-service standards, and agency profitability efforts.

Requirements

  • At least 7 years of personal or commercial lines underwriting experience.
  • At least 5 years of automation experience.
  • At least 3 years of supervisory experience.
  • Excellent organizational and time-management skills.
  • Strong written and verbal communication skills and strong interpersonal skills.
  • Excellent analytical skills.
  • High proficiency with automation, including Outlook, Excel, and Word.
  • Knowledge of Selective systems, such as SelectPLUS®, eSelect®, MCS®, and TARABS®.

Nice To Haves

  • An industry designation such as Associate in Personal Insurance, Certified Insurance Counsel, or Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter.

Responsibilities

  • Manage the underwriting process and contribute to territorial profitability by developing and monitoring underwriting performance and staff expertise.
  • Develop strategic initiatives for the Personal Lines underwriting operation and Service Center that support profit, growth, retention, and service objectives and align with Corporate Personal Lines SBU strategies and goals.
  • Advise team members, personal lines territory managers, agents, claims representatives, and others on complex underwriting issues; make underwriting decisions within prescribed authority; resolve agent complaints; and assist with responses to DOI complaints and market conduct exam inquiries.
  • Ensure staff follow assigned underwriting authority levels and quality and compliance standards through regular consultations, a quality assurance program, and participation in the annual Corporate SBU audit.
  • Ensure staff meet service standards through a service-level self-review program, including monitoring call volume and response times, evaluating recorded calls, and monitoring other customer contact channels.
  • Manage expenses by developing, implementing, and monitoring efficient, cost-effective policies and procedures that support cross-functional teams and resource and task allocation.
  • Identify, develop, implement, and monitor pricing and product development strategies in collaboration with Corporate Personal Lines SBU, Regions, and field staff.
  • Monitor competitors’ products, programs, and pricing and relay competitor intelligence to the Personal Lines product team in a timely manner.
  • Guide and direct staff; ensure training and education on new products and programs and required continuing education; and conduct departmental meetings as needed.
  • Participate in profit and growth analysis by territory and agency, and support agency profit improvement plans by integrating required activities into the daily policy review process.
  • Participate in agency visits and corporate functions, such as territory manager conferences, as needed.

Benefits

  • Competitive base salary.
  • Incentive plan eligibility at all levels.
  • Comprehensive health care plans.
  • Retirement savings plan with company match.
  • Discounted Employee Stock Purchase Program.
  • Tuition assistance and reimbursement programs.
  • 20 days of paid time off.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service