Store Manager - Warrensburg, IL

Casey's•Warrensburg, IL
•$54,000 - $64,700•Onsite

About The Position

Casey’s Store Manager oversees all aspects of operating a successful store, including team management, guest service, merchandising, loss prevention, and food preparation. The role executes company initiatives, drives sales, and maintains quality and service standards while ensuring the store is stocked, clean, and welcoming to guests and the community. The Store Manager hires, trains, develops, and supervises Team Members, serving as a coach and mentor and modeling Casey’s CARES values. The position manages labor and staffing needs, scheduling, kitchen operations, daily store procedures, inventory, merchandise orders, direct store deliveries, and asset-protection processes. The Store Manager partners with the District Manager and store leadership team on action plans tied to performance indicators and profit-and-loss results, and completes required training and assessments. The position offers a customizable career path. Starting pay is $54,000–$64,700, with eligibility for quarterly and annual bonuses based on store and company performance. Actual pay varies based on the candidate’s qualifications and other factors.

Requirements

  • Transferrable professional experience.
  • Ability to prioritize tasks and drive performance to accomplish goals.
  • Ownership mindset.
  • Ability to communicate clearly.
  • Flexibility to take calls as needed and work varied hours, including at least one evening shift per week, every other weekend, and some holidays.
  • Ability to stand and/or walk; lift and/or carry 10–50 pounds; perform repetitive wrist, hand, and finger motions; and reach, bend, stoop, climb, and reach above shoulder level.
  • A background check may be required consistent with state licensing requirements and applicable law.

Nice To Haves

  • Demonstrated ability to build, develop, and lead a team.

Responsibilities

  • Execute Casey’s strategic initiatives, drive sales, and maintain store quality and service standards.
  • Ensure the store is stocked and clean to support strong relationships with guests and the community.
  • Hire, train, develop, and supervise Team Members; coach and mentor the team.
  • Model and coach Casey’s CARES values: Commitment, Authenticity, Respect, Evolving, and Service.
  • Manage the labor budget and staffing needs, including regular hours, special events, and high-traffic periods.
  • Keep the scheduling system current, prepare and post schedules on time, and communicate scheduling updates.
  • Oversee kitchen operations to maximize productivity and profitability.
  • Oversee daily bookwork, Daily Store Walk, Daily Task Lists, required counts, audits, and merchandise orders.
  • Manage inventory and Direct Store Deliveries (DSD).
  • Ensure asset-protection processes and audits are completed to protect company assets.
  • Partner with the District Manager and store leadership team to develop Store Action Plans based on key performance indicators and profit-and-loss statements.
  • Complete required job trainings and assessments, including ServSave Food Protection Manager where applicable, and ensure Team Members complete required training.

Benefits

  • 401(k) with a 6% employer match.
  • Quarterly and annual leadership bonuses subject to performance initiatives.
  • Customizable career path with a Fortune 400 company.
  • Company-paid short-term disability.
  • Health, life, dental, and vision insurance.
  • Paid vacation, sick, and volunteer time off.
  • Paid bonding leave.
  • Well-Being Program.
  • Team Member Perks.
  • Stock purchase plan.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service