Senior Claims Specialist, Property Claims

Vantage Risk Companies•Chicago, IL
•$115,000 - $140,000•Hybrid

About The Position

The Senior Claims Specialist, Property plays a critical role on Vantage’s Property team, providing complete claim management and oversight for assigned claims within the Property and Programs portfolio. The position independently investigates, evaluates, and manages the disposition of Property claims of varying complexity and severity across multiple product types and markets. It also supports the Underwriting Business Unit by liaising with account and broker/agent representatives, providing in-depth exposure analysis to Claims Leadership, and participating in marketing efforts at industry events and conferences. The role reports to the Head of Property Claims and is a remote or hybrid opportunity based in one of Vantage’s offices. The ideal candidate is comfortable in a fast-paced, start-up environment and takes ownership while adapting to change. The base salary expectation is $115,000–$140,000; the selected candidate’s actual base salary and title may be higher based on experience and expectations. Vantage also offers performance-based bonus potential, health and welfare benefits, retirement plans with company match, competitive time-off plans, and a highly flexible work environment.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree or equivalent professional experience.
  • At least five years of Commercial Property claims handling experience at an insurance carrier, including experience with large or complex losses.
  • Active adjuster license(s), or eligibility to obtain one as needed within 90 days of joining.
  • Strong interpersonal skills and ability to communicate effectively and work independently.
  • High positivity, integrity, and dependability, with a strong sense of urgency and results-driven orientation.
  • Developed problem-solving, analytical, and negotiation skills.
  • Working knowledge of Microsoft Office applications, including Word, Outlook, PowerPoint, Planner, and Excel.
  • Ability to process and adapt to change in a rapidly growing company environment.

Nice To Haves

  • Insurance designation such as CPCU, AIC, or AINS.
  • Experience in TPA oversight and/or file quality audits.
  • Experience collaborating with internal stakeholders such as legal, operations, underwriting, and actuaries.
  • Demonstrated commitment to continuous improvement, including personal skill development and identifying efficiencies in claims handling.

Responsibilities

  • Proactively manage assigned first-party Commercial Property shared/layered claims from intake to resolution, including evaluation, reserving, and coverage analysis.
  • Document claim files thoroughly in accordance with company policy, best practices, and regulatory requirements.
  • Draft or review coverage letters and communicate coverage positions to insureds, brokers, and internal stakeholders.
  • Assist with TPA oversight and governance, including conducting assigned audits of Vantage’s Programs and presenting findings to Claims Leadership.
  • Assist with internal projects as assigned.
  • Build and maintain strong relationships with TPA partners, insureds, brokers, agents, and internal stakeholders.
  • Follow Vantage’s reserving, escalation, and reporting protocols.
  • Identify emerging trends across the assigned caseload and the broader Property market, and share insights with Claims Leadership and business partners.
  • Assist during CAT events.
  • Perform other duties as assigned.

Benefits

  • Performance-based bonus potential
  • Strong health and welfare benefits
  • Retirement plans with company match
  • Competitive time-off plans
  • Highly flexible work environment
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service