Personal Lines Underwriter – Plainview, NY | Montvale, NJ | Mt. Laurel, NJ

A & Associates•Montvale, NJ
•$65,000 - $100,000•Hybrid

About The Position

A & Associates is seeking one experienced Personal Lines Underwriter for a confidential search with a respected specialty insurance organization. Preferred locations are Plainview, New York; Montvale, New Jersey; and Mt. Laurel, New Jersey. Remote candidates may be considered. This is a full-time, direct-hire role with a hybrid schedule as assigned by the client. The underwriter reviews, evaluates, and underwrites personal lines submissions; analyzes risk exposures and pricing; and builds productive agency relationships that support profitable portfolio growth. The client is described as having exceptional employee retention, collaborative leadership, innovative technology, hybrid flexibility, and a family-oriented culture. Average employee tenure exceeds ten years, with opportunities for professional growth. Work takes place in a professional office environment on a hybrid schedule, with remote work potentially considered. The culture emphasizes professionalism, service, innovation, respect, initiative, teamwork, and work-life balance. The position offers competitive compensation based on experience, with a stated range of $65,000 to $100,000. The start date is to be determined.

Requirements

  • At least five years of personal lines underwriting experience.
  • MGA or wholesale insurance background; candidates from retail agency, carrier, or MGU backgrounds will not be considered.
  • Active insurance license.
  • Established client portfolio covering NJ, NY, PA, VA, MA, and the broader New England territory; especially required for remote candidates.
  • Strong underwriting and risk analysis skills.
  • Strong relationship management skills with agency partners.
  • Ability to meet high performance expectations in a hybrid work environment.
  • Willingness to complete a Caliper assessment as part of the selection process.

Responsibilities

  • Review, evaluate, and underwrite personal lines submissions.
  • Analyze risk exposures and pricing.
  • Develop and maintain productive agency relationships.
  • Provide underwriting expertise and exceptional service to agency partners.
  • Support profitable portfolio growth.

Benefits

  • 401(k) with employer match
  • Paid time off and holiday pay
  • Wellness incentive program
  • Education assistance
  • Mentorship, goal setting, and coaching
  • Internal growth opportunities
  • State-of-the-art technology
  • Community and philanthropy opportunities
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service