Donor Engagement Manager

Join Our Team!•Bentonville, AR
•$50,000 - $65,000•Onsite

About The Position

The Donor Engagement Manager leads EverHope’s annual giving program to grow revenue, strengthen donor retention, and inspire ongoing support. The role manages direct mail, digital fundraising, monthly giving, donor stewardship, and targeted engagement for new, current, and lapsed donors. Working closely with the Chief Development Officer (CDO), the manager coordinates fundraising campaigns, develops donor communications, and uses donor insights, segmentation, and testing to improve results. The role also collaborates with Marketing & Communications and other internal teams to create a consistent donor experience. The successful candidate is donor-centered, writes compelling fundraising communications, builds relationships, and can manage multiple projects while adapting to changing priorities. The position supports fundraising events and other organizational activities as needed. It requires evening and weekend availability when needed, compliance with background and drug-screening requirements, and the ability to maintain confidentiality and professional boundaries. The role is designated safety-sensitive. The primary outcome is to grow annual giving revenue and build lasting donor relationships through effective campaigns, personalized stewardship, and data-informed engagement. The manager increases donor retention, recurring support, and lapsed-donor reactivation while creating pathways for deeper philanthropic involvement.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree in nonprofit management, hospitality, marketing, communications, business, or a related field, or two years of relevant experience in lieu of a degree.
  • Two or more years of experience in nonprofit fundraising, annual giving, donor relations, communications, or a related field.
  • Pass all criminal history and child maltreatment background checks.
  • Submit to a pre-employment drug screen and random drug screens when directed.
  • Valid driver’s license, proof of personal automobile insurance, and an acceptable driving record; required to drive shelter vehicles for shelter business.
  • Passion for EverHope’s mission and commitment to serving children and families impacted by trauma.
  • Excellent writing and communication skills, including the ability to create compelling donor-centered fundraising communications.
  • Knowledge of annual giving, donor stewardship, retention, and fundraising campaigns.
  • Strong analytical skills and ability to use donor data to inform decisions and improve fundraising results.
  • Experience with CRM systems, donor segmentation, and digital fundraising tools.
  • Strong organizational and project management skills, including the ability to manage multiple campaigns and deadlines.
  • Proficiency with Microsoft Office or Google Workspace and related fundraising technology.
  • Ability to build donor relationships and collaborate effectively across departments.
  • Creativity, initiative, and ability to independently manage projects from planning through execution.
  • Ability to work evenings and weekends as needed for organizational activities.
  • Ability to perform tasks involving walking, standing, climbing, bending, kneeling, crouching, and lifting for extended periods.
  • Ability to lift up to 50 pounds.

Responsibilities

  • Partner with the CDO to establish annual giving goals, priorities, and strategies.
  • Develop and manage the annual calendar of donor cultivation, stewardship, solicitations, and fundraising campaigns.
  • Plan and execute direct mail, email, digital appeals, giving days, and seasonal campaigns.
  • Write donor-centered fundraising appeals, stewardship messages, and campaign communications.
  • Coordinate campaign development, production, and execution with Marketing & Communications, internal teams, and volunteers.
  • Support fundraising events and donor engagement activities in collaboration with the Development team.
  • Manage donor acquisition, renewal, retention, reactivation, and upgrade initiatives.
  • Develop donor journeys that encourage first-time donors to give again and build lasting relationships.
  • Manage EverHope’s Stitched Family monthly giving program, including recruitment, stewardship, retention, and growth.
  • Identify and personally cultivate lapsed donors, including donors who have not given in 18 months or longer, through targeted communications and solicitations.
  • Coordinate donor stewardship, recognition, and appreciation activities.
  • Create CRM reports, custom queries, and segmented donor lists to support fundraising and stewardship.
  • Analyze donor trends and campaign results to track performance, identify opportunities, and improve fundraising effectiveness.
  • Maintain accurate donor records and provide regular performance reports and recommendations to the CDO.
  • Attend and participate in required meetings, training, and organizational events.
  • Maintain confidentiality regarding client information, complete required documentation in a timely manner, and maintain appropriate professional boundaries.

Benefits

  • Excellent benefits
  • Competitive salary based on experience
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service