Program Manager, Community Based Mentoring (Bilingual Spanish)

Big Brothers Big Sisters of New York City Inc•New York, NY
•Hybrid

About The Position

Big Brothers Big Sisters of New York City seeks a youth-focused, service-oriented Program Manager for its Community-Based Mentoring program. The role facilitates high-quality mentoring relationships between adult volunteers (Bigs) and youth (Littles), supporting an average caseload of 55 matches. The Program Manager provides ongoing supervision and guidance to mentors, youth, and parents or guardians; facilitates group activities that support mentoring relationships and youth goals; provides resources and referrals; and conducts intake interviews and psychosocial assessments as needed. Match supervision must be conducted in both English and Spanish. The position reports to an Associate Director or Senior Program Manager and is based in New York, NY, with a hybrid schedule requiring two in-person days at the NYC office.

Requirements

  • Bilingual in English and Spanish.
  • Associate degree in a relevant field and at least 4 years of experience; or bachelor's degree in education, counseling, psychology, social services, or a related field and 1–3 years of direct service experience; or master's degree in mental health counseling, social work, education, or another relevant field and 0–2 years of experience. Applicants with 8 or more years of experience in youth development may be exempt from education standards.
  • Knowledge of child safety and mandatory reporter protocols, and alignment with an asset-based approach to supporting young people and volunteers.
  • Commitment to advancing diversity, equity, and inclusion.
  • Adaptability and flexibility, strong critical thinking and situational judgment, relationship-building ability, and strong administrative and organizational skills.
  • Experience developing and managing relationships with youth clients, guardians, and volunteer mentors.
  • Knowledge and demonstrated experience with intake processes and case management.
  • Strong interpersonal skills and ability to communicate verbally and in writing with individuals and groups.
  • Excellent organizational skills and ability to manage high caseloads and work effectively with clients.
  • Proficiency in Microsoft Office, including Word, Excel, and Outlook.

Nice To Haves

  • Experience conducting psychosocial interviews.
  • Experience using Matchforce and/or Innovative Mentoring systems.

Responsibilities

  • Apply child safety and risk management knowledge, policies, and procedures throughout all aspects of the role, and identify and report child safety issues involving volunteers, children, and families.
  • Supervise a caseload of 55 matches involving youth, parents or guardians, and volunteers, with the goal of building impactful, longer, and stronger mentoring relationships.
  • Conduct match supervision in both English and Spanish.
  • Provide ongoing monthly supervision and support to mentors, mentees, and parents by phone, email, and in person.
  • Conduct psychosocial interviews with clients and parents, write assessments, and collect supporting information from collaborating agencies and schools to determine eligibility, needs, goals, and disposition of service applications.
  • Maintain professional records of supervision contacts and collect surveys on youth outcomes, mentoring relationship strength, and ongoing support needs.
  • Monitor safety, program compliance, goal achievement, and program satisfaction, and promptly address issues that arise.
  • Regularly evaluate youth clients according to agency guidelines and program goals to assess outcomes.
  • Lead educational and recreational group activities or special projects for mentoring pairs and parents based on emerging needs.
  • Advocate for youth and families by providing referrals, crisis intervention, and other resources.
  • Identify and communicate qualitative and quantitative indicators of success within the organization.
  • Perform other organization- and program-related duties as assigned.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service