Manager I, Trust & Safety - Incident Operations

Thumbtack•San Francisco, CA
•$74,000 - $112,200

About The Position

The Trust and Safety Incident Operations Manager leads a team of 6–10 specialists resolving escalated incidents between customers and service professionals. Cases include billing and payment disputes, property damage, theft, mild safety concerns, and Thumbtack Guarantee claims. The manager coaches the team toward fair, defensible outcomes, maintains high standards for quality and speed, and serves as the escalation point for difficult cases. AI is a core part of the work: the manager models and coaches its use while ensuring that people retain ownership of decisions, payouts, and messages. The role partners with Program Managers, Business Applications, senior leadership, and other cross-functional teams to improve processes and the customer journey. It also involves hiring and onboarding, team development, performance management, and creating a safe and inclusive team environment. Expected total cash compensation varies by location: $86,700–$112,200 in the San Francisco/Bay Area, San Jose, New York City, or Seattle metros; $78,200–$101,200 in Austin or Washington, DC metros, or California, Massachusetts, New Jersey, or Washington states; and $74,000–$95,700 in other U.S. locations. Actual offers depend on factors including job level, qualifications, skills, competencies, and proficiency.

Requirements

  • At least 2 years of experience in customer experience, trust and safety, risk, claims, or customer support operations; marketplace or high-volume consumer platform experience is preferred.
  • At least 4 years of direct people-management experience, including giving timely feedback, coaching performance, conducting productive one-on-ones, and supporting employee growth.
  • Hands-on experience with escalated disputes, mediation, claims, or complex case management, including financially or legally sensitive matters and decisions based on conflicting or incomplete information.
  • Ability to identify when to involve Legal, Finance, or leadership in sensitive cases.
  • Experience managing a team against metrics such as SLA, QA, CSAT, and productivity, and using data to identify trends, root causes, and early warning signs and take action.
  • Track record of leading process improvements with cross-functional partners such as Product, Operations, Policy, and Engineering, from problem identification through rollout and impact measurement.
  • Clear, empathetic communication suited to customers, frontline agents, and senior stakeholders; resilience under pressure, urgency, and ownership of outcomes.
  • Hands-on daily use of AI tools and interest in helping a team adopt them responsibly to improve quality, consistency, and efficiency.
  • Sound judgment and discretion when handling confidential information, sensitive customer data, and high-stakes decisions.

Nice To Haves

  • Experience in a marketplace or high-volume consumer platform.

Responsibilities

  • Lead and develop a team of 6–10 specialists through regular one-on-ones, timely feedback, and current development plans.
  • Hold the team accountable for SLA, quality, and CSAT; identify gaps and outliers early and coach accordingly.
  • Set direction, distribute challenging work, establish workload norms, and remove obstacles.
  • Mitigate risks on escalated incidents, including cases with financial or legal implications and Thumbtack Guarantee payouts.
  • Lead the team's use of AI by coaching specialists, building adoption, monitoring emerging risks, and ensuring a person owns each decision, payout, and message.
  • Lead process improvements with Program Managers, Business Applications, and senior leadership.
  • Participate in hiring and onboarding, foster a safe and inclusive team, and remain calibrated with peer managers and cross-functional partners.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service