Subrogation Trial Attorney - Hamilton, NJ (Hybrid)

Selective Insurance Company of AmericaHamilton Township, NJ
Hybrid

About The Position

Selective Insurance is seeking a Subrogation Trial Attorney for our Staff Counsel office in Hamilton, NJ. This is a hybrid role, with 2 days in office and 3 days remote. Provides legal representation to the Company in prosecution of subrogation claims. Provides advice to the subrogation claims department of the Company. Responsible for managing a case load from investigation and inception to resolution. All job duties and responsibilities must be carried out in compliance with applicable legal and regulatory requirements.

Requirements

  • Excellent customer service, writing and oral communication skills required.
  • Ability to demonstrate independent judgment, research, litigation, and analytical skills.
  • Strong legal research and writing skills required.
  • Proficiency in Microsoft Word, Outlook and Edge or Chrome required.
  • Legal case management software experience required
  • Typing skills required.
  • Must have valid state-issued driver’s license in good standing.
  • Juris Doctor degree from ABA accredited law school required.
  • Member in good standing of the New Jersey Bar required, PA preferred.
  • Knowledge of State laws, local court policies and procedures.
  • 7+ years legal experience required.
  • 5+ years of subrogation experience required.

Nice To Haves

  • Detailed knowledge of the business unit and industry preferred.
  • Experience with Litify and dictation software preferred.
  • Trial experience preferred.
  • Multi-state Bar admittance strongly recommended.

Responsibilities

  • Independently represents the Company before the assigned Court and presents witnesses and evidence on subrogation litigation claims.
  • Analyzes complex legal and factual issues, conducts extensive, well-reasoned legal research, independently develops and presents initial strategies on behalf of the Company.
  • Drafts pleadings, written discovery, motions and briefs in support of agreed upon strategies.
  • Prepares for, attends and handles all activities related to full trial and/or appeals, as assigned.
  • Provides effective and timely communications, information, legal advice and other services to clients and subrogation claims professionals on legal and factual issues adhering to our litigation guidelines.
  • Assists in developing training materials for the subrogation Claims Department.
  • Communicates with the Court, witnesses, opposing counsel and clients in a manner consistent with established office procedures and the Code of Professional Conduct.
  • Responsible for the prompt, efficient and effective disposition of assigned cases.
  • Travels to depositions, court appearances, claims and client meetings, and other events as necessary. Car travel represents approximately 20% of employee’s time.
  • Keeps current with market trends and demands.
  • Attends continuing legal education seminars in order to maintain a high level of professional expertise.
  • Performs all other functionally related duties as assigned by the Managing Attorney.
  • Provides legal representation to Selective on litigated claims.
  • Provides advice to our subrogation claims partners and represents Selective in certain litigated matters.
  • Responsible for managing a case load from investigation and inception to resolution.
  • Analyzes legal and factual issues, conducts legal research, and independently develops and advances agreed upon strategies on behalf of the Company.

Benefits

  • competitive base salary
  • incentive plan eligibility
  • comprehensive health care plans
  • retirement savings plan with company match
  • discounted Employee Stock Purchase Program
  • tuition assistance and reimbursement programs
  • 20 days of paid time off
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service