Subrogation Trial Attorney - Hamilton, NJ (Hybrid)

Selective Insurance Company of America•Tredyffrin Township, PA
•Hybrid

About The Position

Selective Insurance is seeking a Subrogation Trial Attorney for its Staff Counsel office in Hamilton, New Jersey. This hybrid role requires two days in the office and three days remote. The attorney provides legal representation to Selective in subrogation and other assigned litigated claims, advises the subrogation claims department and partners, and manages cases from investigation and inception through resolution. Duties must be performed in compliance with applicable legal and regulatory requirements.

Requirements

  • Juris Doctor degree from an ABA-accredited law school.
  • Member in good standing of the New Jersey Bar.
  • Knowledge of state laws and local court policies and procedures.
  • At least 7 years of legal experience.
  • At least 5 years of subrogation experience.
  • Excellent customer service, writing, and oral communication skills.
  • Ability to demonstrate independent judgment, research, litigation, and analytical skills.
  • Strong legal research and writing skills.
  • Proficiency in Microsoft Word, Outlook, and Edge or Chrome.
  • Experience with legal case management software.
  • Typing skills.
  • Valid state-issued driver's license in good standing.

Nice To Haves

  • Pennsylvania Bar membership.
  • Detailed knowledge of the business unit and industry.
  • Experience with Litify and dictation software.
  • Trial experience.
  • Multi-state Bar admission is strongly recommended.

Responsibilities

  • Independently represent the Company before assigned courts and present witnesses and evidence in subrogation litigation claims.
  • Analyze complex legal and factual issues, conduct legal research, and independently develop and advance strategies on the Company's behalf.
  • Draft pleadings, written discovery, motions, and briefs in support of agreed-upon strategies.
  • Prepare for, attend, and handle activities related to trials and appeals as assigned.
  • Provide timely communications, information, legal advice, and other services to clients and subrogation claims professionals while following litigation guidelines.
  • Assist in developing training materials for the subrogation Claims Department.
  • Communicate with courts, witnesses, opposing counsel, and clients consistent with office procedures and the Code of Professional Conduct.
  • Promptly, efficiently, and effectively dispose of assigned cases.
  • Travel to depositions, court appearances, claims and client meetings, and other events as necessary; car travel is approximately 20% of the employee's time.
  • Keep current with market trends and demands.
  • Attend continuing legal education seminars to maintain a high level of professional expertise.
  • Perform other functionally related duties as assigned by the Managing Attorney.
  • Carry out all duties in compliance with applicable legal and regulatory requirements.

Benefits

  • Competitive base salary.
  • Incentive plan eligibility at all levels.
  • Comprehensive health care plans.
  • Retirement savings plan with company match.
  • Discounted Employee Stock Purchase Program.
  • Tuition assistance and reimbursement programs.
  • 20 days of paid time off.

Stand Out From the Crowd

Upload your resume and get instant feedback on how well it matches this job.

Upload and Match Resume

What This Job Offers

Job Type

Full-time

Career Level

Senior

Education Level

Ph.D. or professional degree

© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service