Store Manager - Trafalgar, IN

Casey’s•Trafalgar, IN
•Onsite

About The Position

Casey’s Store Manager oversees all aspects of operating a successful store, including team management, guest service, merchandising, loss prevention, and food preparation. The role is responsible for creating a fun and helpful store atmosphere for guests, team members, and the community, while executing company initiatives and maintaining quality and service standards. Casey’s offers a customizable career path for continued growth in management and leadership. The position is eligible for quarterly and annual bonuses based on store and company performance. Starting pay range is $51,300–$61,400; actual pay may vary based on candidate qualifications, local prevailing wages, and internal equity.

Requirements

  • Transferrable professional experience.
  • Ability to prioritize tasks and drive performance to accomplish goals.
  • Ownership mindset.
  • Ability to communicate clearly.
  • Flexibility to take calls as needed and work varied hours, including at least one evening shift per week, every other weekend, and some holidays.
  • Ability to stand and/or walk; lift and/or carry 10–50 pounds; use repetitive wrist, hand, and/or finger motions; and reach, bend, stoop, climb, and reach above shoulder level.
  • A background check may be consistent with state licensing requirements and applicable law.

Nice To Haves

  • Demonstrated ability to build, develop, and lead a team.

Responsibilities

  • Execute Casey’s strategic initiatives, drive sales, and maintain quality and service standards.
  • Keep the store stocked and clean and build strong relationships with guests and the community.
  • Hire, train, develop, and supervise team members; coach and mentor them to help them succeed and grow.
  • Model and coach Casey’s CARES values: Commitment, Authenticity, Respect, Evolving, and Service.
  • Manage the labor budget and meet staffing needs for regular hours, special events, and high-traffic periods.
  • Keep the scheduling system current, prepare and post schedules on time, and communicate scheduling updates.
  • Oversee kitchen operations to maximize productivity and profitability.
  • Complete daily bookwork, the Daily Store Walk, Daily Task Lists, counts, audits, and merchandise orders; manage inventory and Direct Store Deliveries (DSD).
  • Ensure asset protection processes and audits are completed to protect company assets.
  • Partner with the District Manager and store leadership team to develop Store Action Plans in response to performance indicators and profit and loss statements.
  • Attend and complete required job trainings and assessments, including ServSafe Food Protection Manager where applicable, and ensure team members complete required training.

Benefits

  • 401(k) with a 6% employer match
  • Quarterly and annual leadership bonuses subject to performance initiatives
  • Customizable career path with a Fortune 400 company
  • Company-paid short-term disability
  • Health, life, dental, and vision insurance
  • Paid vacation, sick, and volunteer time off
  • Paid bonding leave
  • Well-being program
  • Team member perks
  • Stock purchase plan
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service