Sr. Litigation Attorney-NJ/PA

CSAA Insurance Group, a AAA Insurer•New Jersey - Home Teleworkers, NJ
•$152,010 - $202,550•Remote

About The Position

The Sr. Litigation Attorney provides legal advice, counsel, and representation for insureds and/or CSAA IG before courts and arbitration panels, and advises company employees on claim matters. The attorney prepares legal pleadings, motions, statements, and trial briefs; negotiates settlements; and advocates on behalf of CSAA IG and its insureds. The role handles all phases of personal injury litigation, including jury trials, motions, and arbitration hearings, and requires specialized experience in property and casualty insurance defense, insurance principles, and legal developments affecting the insurance industry and personal injury litigation. The attorney uses independent judgment to resolve issues, including highly complex matters, with limited oversight from a managing attorney. Substantial trial experience and the ability to lead trials and arbitration proceedings, including complex matters and non-traditional property and casualty disputes, are required. The attorney may support Attorney I, II, and IV roles and mentor Attorney I and II attorneys as needed.

Requirements

  • Proficiency in personal injury litigation, including liability assessment, causation, damages, coverage, and the tripartite relationship.
  • Advanced knowledge of liability insurance coverage and CSAA IG policies.
  • Excellent verbal and written communication skills, with the ability to communicate in an organized and timely manner.
  • Strong negotiation skills.
  • Proficient computer skills, including Microsoft Office and online research tools.
  • Ability to efficiently manage a complex case inventory and prioritize multiple tasks.
  • Ability to advocate creatively, persuasively, and effectively.
  • Advanced analytical and legal skills, including the ability to think and act independently in a client’s best interest.
  • Knowledge and understanding of legal ethics.
  • Advanced degree in a related area requiring a law degree and passing the bar exam.
  • Certification(s) and/or license(s) in the functional area and a license from the state of practice.
  • 10–12+ years of experience in insurance defense practice, with considerable courtroom and first-chair trial experience.

Responsibilities

  • Use independent analysis and judgment to prepare pleadings, motions, statements, trial briefs, and related legal materials in coordination with claims specialists.
  • Represent and advocate for CSAA IG and its member insureds.
  • Handle assigned cases, including highly complex and high-exposure cases, through all phases of litigation, including motions, arbitration hearings, trials, and appeals.
  • Assist in coaching and mentoring Attorney I and II positions.
  • Handle highly complex legal matters and projects, including matters that are not in litigation.
  • Serve as a resource for the office and Claims organization.
  • Serve as a resource in assigned legal disciplines and independently resolve major issues within the legal specialty area.
  • Anticipate and advise on potential legal issues that significantly affect insurance and tort litigation.
  • Negotiate settlements and advise company employees on claim matters.

Benefits

  • Opportunity to participate in a company-wide annual discretionary bonus through the Annual Incentive Plan, up to 12% of eligible pay.

Stand Out From the Crowd

Upload your resume and get instant feedback on how well it matches this job.

Upload and Match Resume

What This Job Offers

Job Type

Full-time

Career Level

Senior

Education Level

Ph.D. or professional degree

© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service