Senior Strategy & Performance Analyst

First Chicago Insurance Company (FCIC)•Chicago, IL
•$100 - $175

About The Position

First Chicago is hiring a Senior Strategy & Performance Analyst to investigate why business results change and help address the drivers, with Claims as the primary focus. The role examines adverse trends and deviations from KPIs, works with business leaders to develop practical corrective actions, and tracks those actions through to measured results. It is focused on root-cause analysis and follow-through—not dashboard production, budgeting, forecasting, or ownership of departmental operations. The analyst reports to the Chief Accounting Officer & Treasurer and works closely with Financial Planning & Analysis, Accounting, department leadership, and Product & Actuarial. A dedicated data analyst supports the role. The analyst coordinates cross-functional analysis and dependencies without taking authority over departmental decisions or implementation, and supports technical owners while actuarial judgments, underwriting decisions, and Claims operations remain with their respective departments. The primary focus is Claims, including claim severity and frequency, loss ratios and development trends, handling trends, cycle times, attorney representation, litigation, complaints, vendor costs, loss adjustment expenses, and state or program variances. Assigned secondary areas may include Personal Lines and Commercial Lines Underwriting, Marketing, and Product & Actuarial. Success is measured by credible root-cause findings, adopted recommendations, completed corrective actions, verified benefits against documented baselines, sustained KPI improvement, and useful executive reporting.

Requirements

  • Bachelor's degree in Finance, Accounting, Business, Economics, Analytics, Insurance, or a related field, or equivalent experience.
  • Five or more years of relevant experience in P&C insurance, insurance operations, business performance analysis, strategic planning, or a related field.
  • In-depth knowledge of P&C Claims operations and metrics.
  • Working knowledge of Underwriting, Product/Actuarial, and distribution.
  • Strong analytical, financial, and problem-solving skills, including the ability to connect operational drivers to business results and evaluate cost-benefit and ROI.
  • Excellent executive communication, facilitation, and judgment, with the ability to influence without direct authority.
  • Advanced Excel skills.
  • Proficiency with SQL and BI/data visualization tools.

Nice To Haves

  • P&C Claims experience is strongly preferred.
  • Cross-functional insurance experience is strongly preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Review KPI reports, financial results, operating metrics, and strategic milestones; identify exceptions, emerging risks, and significant deviations from targets.
  • Investigate underlying causes by state, carrier, program, product, distribution channel, department, and vendor using the data lake and source systems; distinguish temporary fluctuations from persistent problems.
  • Validate findings with department leaders and subject-matter experts, constructively challenge assumptions, and distinguish observed facts from hypotheses.
  • Develop corrective-action plans with accountable department heads, including owners, timelines, milestones, and success measures.
  • Identify opportunities to reduce costs, improve profitability, optimize resources, and increase productivity; assess return on investment in coordination with Accounting.
  • Maintain a central tracker of approved actions, monitor progress and measured results, assess whether improvements hold, and escalate unresolved issues.
  • Coordinate cross-functional analysis and dependencies without assuming authority over departmental decisions or implementation.
  • Prepare concise monthly executive summaries covering priority exceptions, confirmed causes, recommended actions, owners, progress, quantified benefits, and open risks.
  • Align with enterprise KPI definitions; use existing reports when timely and sufficient, and work with the data analyst to develop supplemental data and reports when needed.
  • Analyze Claims metrics and trends, including severity, frequency, loss ratios, loss development, handling, cycle times, attorney representation, litigation, complaints, vendor costs, loss adjustment expenses, and state or program variances.
  • Support assigned analyses in Personal Lines Underwriting, Commercial Lines Underwriting, Marketing, and Product & Actuarial.
  • Track success through timely and credible root-cause findings, adopted recommendations, completed corrective actions, verified savings or operational benefits, sustained KPI improvement, and decision-useful executive reporting.

Benefits

  • Competitive salaries
  • Training and development
  • Medical and dental benefits
  • Telemedicine benefit
  • 401(k) with a generous company match
  • Paid time off
  • Paid holidays
  • Tuition reimbursement training programs
  • Wellness program
  • Company-sponsored events
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service