Senior/Executie Underwriter-Middle Market Solutions Midwest

Crum & Forster•Chicago, IN
•$78,600 - $147,700•Hybrid

About The Position

Crum & Forster’s Commercial Lines division provides specialized insurance solutions for mid-sized and large businesses. The Middle Market Solutions department is expanding its regional footprint and seeks an experienced, market-facing production underwriter to drive profitable growth in an assigned territory. This hybrid role is based in the Chicago area and works closely with regional management as a lead production underwriter and regional underwriting contact. The underwriter will develop broker relationships and account pipelines, analyze underwriting data, select risks, and build and maintain a profitable book of business. The role manages agency relationships through customer service, innovation, and visibility; collaborates with internal and external partners to meet profitability and growth goals; and supports cross-selling within Crum & Forster and the broader Fairfax entities. The position calls for an independent, entrepreneurial, team-oriented approach and openness to an AI-enabled underwriting environment.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree or equivalent experience.
  • At least 6 years of underwriting experience.
  • Strong relationships with agencies in the assigned territories.
  • Strong underwriting knowledge of Property, General Liability, Automobile, and Workers’ Compensation.
  • Knowledge of lines of business within Manufacturing, Retail, Wholesale, Real Estate, and other general industry risks.
  • Strong communication and analytical skills for pursuing new business and managing a renewal book.
  • Proficiency in software needed to succeed in the department.
  • Knowledge of and experience with territory-specific broker relationships.
  • Excellent organizational and time-management skills.
  • Current driver’s license, as travel may be required.

Nice To Haves

  • Possesses or is pursuing underwriting and industry designations applicable to the area of specialization.
  • Innovative and entrepreneurial spirit, with a flexible and dynamic approach to business and willingness to embrace an AI-assisted underwriting environment.

Responsibilities

  • Serve as the lead underwriting contact for the regional territory and work directly with Regional Management.
  • Manage regional broker planning, analysis, and development as the lead broker relationship contact for assigned brokers.
  • Assist in developing annual business goals for assigned agents and producers; analyze results and maintain agency-partner accountability.
  • Meet department profitability, retention, and written premium goals.
  • Make independent underwriting decisions within the underwriting letter of authority and maintain proper file documentation.
  • Underwrite Property, Auto, General Liability, Workers’ Compensation, and Excess lines for a variety of Middle Market risks.
  • Seek growth opportunities with assigned brokers.
  • Represent the assigned Middle Market region at key industry functions and events.
  • Maintain in-depth knowledge of department products, services, and processes, and clearly communicate the department’s and company’s value proposition.
  • Participate in training and initiatives to develop knowledge; may participate in projects.
  • Travel as required.
  • Perform other duties as assigned.

Benefits

  • Flexible work arrangements.
  • Competitive compensation package.
  • Generous 401K employer match.
  • Employee Stock Purchase plan with employer matching.
  • Generous Paid Time Off.
  • Benefits including health, dental, and vision coverage, plus wellness programs focused on physical and mental wellbeing.
  • Tuition reimbursement, industry-related certifications, and professional training.
  • Matching donation program and volunteer opportunities.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service