Remote Recruiter (Insurance Agent Focus)

trainwell•Tiffin, IA
•$75,000 - $90,000•Remote

About The Position

trainwell is a national training company that helps high-performing insurance agencies scale revenue through sales systems, accountability structures, and performance training. The company has launched a recruiting division to help its agency clients hire talent. This is a client-facing recruiting role, not an internal HR position. The Recruiter partners with a portfolio of insurance agency clients across the country and executes and scales the recruiting framework established by the Founding Recruiting Lead. The role manages a high volume of open positions, delivers talent to agency owners, and helps refine the division’s processes. The Recruiter owns full-cycle hiring for roles such as Insurance Sales Producers, Account Managers, and hybrid customer service positions. The role involves sourcing beyond job postings and inbound applications, partnering with agency owners, evaluating candidates, coordinating structured group interviews, and improving recruiting workflows and metrics.

Requirements

  • At least 2 years of full-cycle recruiting experience.
  • Strong organization and a metrics-minded approach; understanding of the recruiting funnel and how to move candidates efficiently without sacrificing quality.
  • Comfort communicating with business owners and holding them accountable to timelines and hiring standards, including the ability to push back professionally when necessary.
  • Ability to work autonomously with minimal oversight and manage multiple open roles across different time zones.

Nice To Haves

  • Experience recruiting in an agency setting or a high-volume corporate environment.
  • Experience recruiting for sales or insurance roles.

Responsibilities

  • Manage the end-to-end recruiting process for Insurance Sales Producers, Account Managers, and hybrid customer service positions, using sourcing methods beyond job postings and inbound applications.
  • Serve as the primary recruiting contact for agency owners; manage expectations, provide market insights, and guide clients through hiring.
  • Screen candidates for cultural fit, sales aptitude, and technical insurance knowledge.
  • Coordinate and help administer structured group interviews with agency owners.
  • Work within and help improve recruiting systems, documentation, and workflows.
  • Track recruiting KPIs and placement metrics to support efficiency and quality.
  • Manage multiple open roles across clients and time zones autonomously.
  • Help refine and scale the recruiting division’s processes.

Benefits

  • Commission per successful placement
  • Performance bonuses
  • Health insurance
  • 401(k) with match and Roth 401(k)
  • PTO
  • Life insurance
  • Disability insurance
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service