Payroll & Benefits Specialist

Careers In Nonprofits•Brooklyn, NY
•Onsite

About The Position

The Payroll & Benefits Specialist will report to the Chief Financial & Operating Officer and will be responsible for the administration of all payroll-related functions, management of payroll data, compliance, reporting and reconciliation and for administering benefits programs. This role is ideal for a proactive, detail-oriented candidate with excellent interpersonal skills.

Requirements

  • 5 years of experience administering payroll and benefits with extensive knowledge of HR functions
  • Bachelor’s degree in Human Resources, Business Administration, or related field
  • Strong knowledge of federal, state and local laws and regulations impacting payroll operations
  • Excellent organization skills with a strong attention to detail while managing multiple tasks simultaneously
  • Strong communication and interpersonal skills
  • Proficient with ADP and MS Office/Google Suite including Excel

Nice To Haves

  • Prior experience working in a school setting a plus

Responsibilities

  • Accurately process semi-monthly payroll using ADP while ensuring compliance with federal, state and local payroll, wage and hour laws and best practices.
  • Prepare and enter payroll journal entries into NXT accounting platform.
  • Respond to employee questions related to payroll and provide support to employees for utilizing ADP self-service.
  • Maintain accurate employee payroll records including tax withholding forms, payroll deductions, changes in employee status and other payroll information.
  • Review employee contributions and deductions for accuracy and consistency with employee election of benefits.
  • Maintain employee data integrity and ensure confidentiality and security of data.
  • Review periodic employer federal and state tax returns and ensure payroll tax deposits are timely and accurate.
  • Develop the schedules, calendars, and communications for payroll.
  • Administer all aspects of employee benefits plans including health, dental, vision, short-term and long-term disability, group term and voluntary life, worker’s compensation, 403(b) retirement, unemployment and pre-tax expense programs.
  • Enhance the employee experience by ensuring timely, knowledgeable, and empathetic responses to all benefits inquiries.
  • Manage benefit plan operations, plan changes and benefit-related claims, including open enrollments; administer open enrollment in ADP and ensure data flows correctly to Health Equity, etc.
  • Serve as primary contact with carriers and third-party administrators, respond to benefits inquiries from employees relating to status changes, plan provisions, and other general inquiries.
  • Process, review and respond to unemployment claims and worker’s comp claims with appropriate documentation. Review unemployment statements.
  • Reconcile bills by producing and balancing reports to ensure accuracy of billing.
  • Process monthly billings and administrative fees for all group plans accurately and timely.
  • Process leave of absence requests, disability paperwork, FMLA, medical and personal leaves.
  • Oversee the running of effective and strategic use of ADP, including ensuring its data integrity.
  • Participate in and prepare reports and reconciliations for the annual year-end financial audit, IRS 990, 403b, 5500, 8955, and Workers Compensation audits.
  • Maintain compliance with federal, state and local employment laws and regulations and review policies to maintain compliance.
  • Gather data for compliance reporting, including the NYC EDC bond compliance reporting and the annual DASL reporting.
  • Serve as a backup for onboarding in ADP and the creation of ID cards.
  • Support the human resources function of the school, as needed.

Benefits

  • health
  • dental
  • vision
  • short-term and long-term disability
  • group term and voluntary life
  • worker’s compensation
  • 403(b) retirement
  • unemployment
  • pre-tax expense programs
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service