Payroll/AP Accountant

Milwaukee Repertory Theater•Milwaukee, WI
•$55,000 - $65,000

About The Position

Milwaukee Repertory Theater is seeking a detail-oriented, deadline-driven Payroll/AP Accountant to support accurate payroll, accounts payable, and related accounting operations. The role manages multiple recurring payroll and payables deadlines and calls for an organized, versatile team player who communicates effectively across departments. It offers growth opportunities for an accounting professional interested in supporting the theater’s mission. The position processes four employee payrolls on weekly and bi-weekly schedules, maintains payroll records and union contract rates, and reconciles payroll accounting entries and liabilities. It also handles invoices, vendor records and statements, and the theater’s credit card reconciliation process. Additional duties include contractor and agent contract administration, 1099 reporting, support for grant reporting and financial analysis, and backup coverage for team members.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree, preferably in Accounting, Finance, or a related field.
  • 2–5 years of direct payroll experience.
  • Proficiency with accounting software.
  • Experience with payroll systems and software.
  • Experience with accounts payable systems and software.
  • Strong understanding of balance sheet reconciliation processes.
  • Intermediate Excel skills; Excel is used daily for reconciliations and reporting, and finalists will complete a short Excel exercise.
  • Exceptional attention to detail and ability to maintain accuracy under tight deadlines.
  • Strong analytical and problem-solving abilities.
  • Self-motivation and ability to work independently and manage priorities.
  • Excellent interpersonal skills and ability to collaborate across departments.
  • Strong written and verbal communication skills, including the ability to explain financial information clearly to non-finance stakeholders.
  • Systems thinking and a drive to improve processes and build efficiency.
  • Curiosity and eagerness to learn all aspects of theater financial operations.
  • Flexibility and adaptability to take on diverse responsibilities and provide backup support.

Nice To Haves

  • Payroll experience in a nonprofit or organization with union contracts.
  • Experience with Sage Intacct.
  • Experience with Paylocity.
  • Experience with Bill.com.
  • Familiarity with nonprofit accounting principles and fund accounting.

Responsibilities

  • Process four employee payrolls on weekly and bi-weekly schedules.
  • Maintain accurate payroll system records, including employee information, withholdings, deductions, and union contract rates.
  • Ensure payroll compliance with union contracts.
  • Process wage garnishments and court-ordered deductions.
  • Coordinate with Human Resources on new hires, terminations, and benefits changes.
  • Prepare annual workers’ compensation audit and census data for benefit providers.
  • Identify payroll process improvements and reduce manual work.
  • Reconcile monthly general ledger entries and liability accounts, investigate discrepancies, explain variances, and ensure accruals are accurate and timely.
  • Process and code invoices and maintain accurate vendor records.
  • Coordinate with departments to ensure invoices are accurately processed and posted to the general ledger.
  • Reconcile vendor statements and investigate discrepancies.
  • Support accurate recording of accounts payable transactions, including expense coding, accruals, and liability tracking.
  • Assist with administration of the company credit card system, including cardholder setup and policy enforcement.
  • Monitor credit card transactions for policy compliance and appropriate business use.
  • Manage monthly credit card reconciliations, ensuring charges are reviewed, approved, and coded.
  • Ensure credit card transactions are recorded with proper documentation and general ledger coding.
  • Address credit card policy violations and work with cardholders to resolve missing receipts or documentation.
  • Maintain contractor and agent contracts, understand contract terms and payment structures, and set up vendors accordingly.
  • Manage 1099 year-end reporting and reconciliation.
  • Organize and maintain the contract filing system, identify multi-year contracts for audit purposes, and flag upcoming renewals or expirations.
  • Support management with ad hoc financial analysis and special projects.
  • Support grant reporting and compliance requirements.
  • Provide backup coverage for team members during planned leaves and absences.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service