Direct Response & Direct Mail Manager

American Forests US,
$85,000 - $110,000Remote

About The Position

The Digital & Direct Response Manager owns execution for American Forests' multichannel direct response fundraising strategy: direct mail, email and online giving as well as other communications that Compass Digital is currently driving for the organization as a whole. The manager supports the annual calendar, interacts with creative and content production, manages outside print/mail vendors and works closely with the philanthropy team to maximize direct and digital fundraising.

Requirements

  • 5+ years in direct response fundraising or direct marketing, preferably in a nonprofit setting.
  • Demonstrated ownership of direct mail and email/online campaigns from strategy through analysis.
  • Hands-on experience with fundraising/CRM and marketing platforms; Luminate and/or HubSpot experience strongly preferred.
  • Strong analytical skills and comfort with segmentation, testing and ROI reporting.
  • Excellent project management and vendor-management skills.
  • Bachelor's degree or equivalent experience; commitment to American Forests' conservation mission.

Responsibilities

  • Execute the annual direct response plan across direct mail, email and online giving including acquisition, renewal, year-end, special appeals and monthly/sustainer giving.
  • Work with campaign creative direction, copy and production schedules; manage print and mail-house vendors selectively rather than through a full-service agency.
  • Manage segmentation, list selection, testing and donor journeys to grow retention, average gift and sustainer conversion.
  • Own program analytics by tracking costs, response, revenue and ROI by channel and campaign, and reporting results to leadership.
  • Administer and optimize the fundraising technology stack; operate Luminate near term and lead the evaluation and migration to HubSpot.
  • Ensure donor data integrity, gift coding accuracy and compliance with USPS nonprofit mailing and fundraising regulations.
  • Partner with development, communications and finance to align messaging, budgets and revenue targets.

Benefits

  • medical, dental, and vision coverage
  • vacation and sick leave
  • paid holidays
  • a 401(k) with match
  • flexible spending accounts
  • disability, life, and AD&D insurance
  • parental bonding and bereavement leave
  • an employee assistance program
  • a technology stipend
  • pet benefits
  • military leave
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service