Annual Giving Manager

BHI Senior Living•Indianapolis, IN

About The Position

BHI Senior Living is seeking an Annual Giving Manager to strengthen annual fundraising and donor relationships across BHI Foundation’s six Indiana communities. The role develops and evaluates fundraising campaigns, grows recurring giving, and communicates the impact of donor support in service of enriching the lives of older adults. The manager sets annual giving goals and campaign plans with Foundation leadership, oversees budgets and performance, cultivates donors and prospects, and personally solicits annual gifts of up to $10,000. The position leads integrated direct mail and digital campaigns, develops donor-centered messaging, manages stewardship and recognition, and uses performance data to improve results. It also coordinates donor transitions to major or planned giving colleagues and collaborates with Foundation Operations, Marketing & Communications, community Executive Directors, Major Gifts Officers, and other Foundation colleagues.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree in fundraising, communications, marketing, business, nonprofit management, or a related field.
  • Three to five years of experience in annual giving, fundraising, nonprofit marketing, donor relations, or a related field.
  • Experience planning and executing direct response fundraising campaigns, including direct mail and digital appeals.
  • Experience using donor relationship management systems.
  • Strong written communication skills, including the ability to develop compelling, donor-centered fundraising messages.
  • Demonstrated project management skills and ability to manage multiple campaigns, deadlines, and priorities simultaneously.
  • Strong analytical skills and ability to interpret fundraising performance data to guide decisions and improve results.
  • Excellent interpersonal, relationship-building, organizational, and communication skills.
  • Ability to collaborate across teams and communities while exercising independent judgment and maintaining confidentiality.

Nice To Haves

  • Certified Fund Raising Executive (CFRE) credential.
  • Familiarity with Blackbaud Raiser’s Edge NXT.
  • Experience with fundraising analytics, donor segmentation, campaign testing, and performance measurement.
  • Experience in senior living, healthcare, or other mission-driven nonprofit organizations.
  • Familiarity with digital fundraising platforms, online giving tools, and donor engagement technologies.

Responsibilities

  • Develop, implement, and evaluate an annual giving strategy across six Indiana communities, including fundraising goals, campaign objectives, calendars, and revenue projections.
  • Manage the annual giving budget, monitor progress, and adjust strategies to improve donor participation, retention, and revenue.
  • Build and manage relationships with annual donors and prospects, cultivating engagement, recurring giving, and sustained support.
  • Identify, qualify, and cultivate new donors through targeted outreach, and personally solicit and secure annual gifts of up to $10,000.
  • Lead fundraising campaigns including direct mail, email, digital appeals, Giving Day initiatives, year-end appeals, monthly giving, and employee giving.
  • Develop campaign themes and donor-centered messages that communicate the impact of giving.
  • Manage direct mail campaigns from concept through production, distribution, and evaluation, coordinating vendors, mailing requirements, schedules, quality, and costs.
  • Partner with Foundation Operations on donor lists, audience segmentation, communication preferences, and campaign selections.
  • Coordinate direct mail and digital fundraising, including emails, QR codes, personalized URLs, landing pages, and A/B testing.
  • Create stewardship plans, impact reports, acknowledgments, and recognition initiatives tailored to donor preferences.
  • Identify donors who may be ready for major or planned gifts and coordinate transitions to Community Major Gifts Officers or Foundation leadership.
  • Analyze campaign response rates, donor acquisition costs, retention, average gift size, recurring giving, and return on investment.
  • Collaborate with Foundation Operations on fundraising reports, dashboards, and performance metrics for Foundation leadership.
  • Partner with Marketing & Communications, community Executive Directors, Major Gifts Officers, and Foundation colleagues to align fundraising with community priorities and support events and other initiatives.

Benefits

  • 401(k) match up to 5%.
  • Medical, dental, and vision insurance.
  • Employer-paid life insurance.
  • Paid time off earned from the first day of employment.
  • Paid holidays.
  • Access to an Employee Assistance Program (EAP).
  • Student loan repayment and tuition assistance.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service