Annual Giving Manager

ACTORS FUND OF AMERICA•New York, NY
•Hybrid

About The Position

The Entertainment Community Fund seeks an Annual Giving Manager to manage its direct response fundraising program, including membership, appeals, acquisition, cultivation, email campaigns, digital advertising, and SMS, as well as recurring giving and midlevel donor stewardship. The position is based at the Fund’s National Headquarters Office in Times Square, New York City, and currently follows a hybrid schedule with an expectation of working in the office two to three days per week. The manager coordinates the review, editing, and approval of strategies and creative materials for direct response fundraising, ensuring alignment with organizational brand guidelines. The role evaluates fundraising materials such as membership renewals, welcome series, digital advertisements, and donation forms, and manages online giving to support a cohesive donor experience. It also oversees the recurring giving program and serves as its primary donor contact. Working with program staff, the manager identifies and interviews clients for fundraising appeals and donor impact reporting. The manager maintains a portfolio of approximately 50–75 midlevel donors; prepares acknowledgment letters as needed; processes donations; and participates in the cultivation, stewardship, and retention of midlevel and major donors. The role also serves as a secondary contact for donor Broadway house seat order fulfillment.

Requirements

  • At least three years of experience working in Individual Giving at a nonprofit institution, preferably in direct response, annual giving, and/or donor relations.
  • Meticulous writing, proofreading, and editing skills.
  • Strong organizational skills and attention to detail.
  • Strong interpersonal skills, emotional intelligence, and cultural competence.
  • Ability to communicate effectively with individuals from various backgrounds.
  • Knowledge and appreciation of the performing arts and entertainment industry, particularly the current Broadway landscape.
  • Moderate to high proficiency with Microsoft Office, including Outlook, Word, Excel, and PowerPoint.
  • Comfort learning new technologies, including CRMs and ticketing programs.
  • Availability for occasional evening and weekend events outside regular working hours.

Nice To Haves

  • Experience using Raiser’s Edge or another fundraising CRM database.
  • Ticketing or box office experience.
  • Interest in continued growth and education in Individual Giving.

Responsibilities

  • Manage the direct response fundraising program, including membership, appeals, acquisition, cultivation, email campaigns, digital advertising, and SMS.
  • Manage recurring giving and serve as the primary point of contact for recurring donors.
  • Coordinate review, editing, and approval of direct response fundraising strategies, copy, and artwork, ensuring consistency with organizational brand guidelines.
  • Review and evaluate fundraising materials, including membership renewals, welcome series, digital advertisements, and donation forms.
  • Manage online giving and ensure its elements operate as designed to provide a cohesive donor experience.
  • Work with program staff to identify and conduct client interviews for fundraising appeals and donor impact reporting.
  • Maintain a portfolio of approximately 50–75 midlevel donors.
  • Create acknowledgment letters as needed and process donations.
  • Participate in the cultivation, stewardship, and retention of midlevel and major donors.
  • Serve as a secondary contact for donor Broadway house seat order fulfillment.

Benefits

  • Choice of multiple health plans.
  • Dental plan.
  • Voluntary vision plan.
  • Flexible spending and dependent care plans.
  • Employer-paid life and long-term disability insurance.
  • Supplemental life and disability insurance.
  • 401(k) plan with generous employer match.
  • Tuition reimbursement.
  • Generous paid time off.
  • Wage Works commuter benefit.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service