Account Executive - Personal Lines

Ansay & Associates•Menomonie, WI

About The Position

Under the direction of the Director of Sales, the Personal Lines Account Executive generates new business sales to drive organic growth and provides high-level customer service to retain and service Personal Lines accounts. The role suits someone who enjoys networking, demonstrates a high level of professionalism, and is passionate about personalized client service. The Account Executive prospects and qualifies new accounts, develops new business through networking and referrals, identifies cross-selling opportunities, and works toward annual revenue and retention goals. The position also manages an assigned book of business using the Epic Agency Management System, services policies, supports clients with coverage education, and acts as a claims advocate when applicable. The role partners with colleagues across Personal Lines, Commercial Lines, and Employee Benefits to present personal insurance as a voluntary employee benefit. The position reports to the Director of Sales and requires a bachelor’s degree in Business or a related field, prior related sales and service experience, and a Property & Casualty license as required by the state. A Life license and additional designations are preferred. Strong communication, analytical, organizational, technical, and interpersonal skills are important, along with initiative, teamwork, professionalism, and a commitment to continuing development. Ansay describes itself as a growing, family-owned, employee-focused insurance agency that values collaboration, continuous improvement, and professional growth. It invests in employees through training, technology, and career development opportunities and emphasizes lasting client relationships and its stated core values.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree in Business or another related degree.
  • Related experience, including previous sales and service experience.
  • Property & Casualty license per state requirements.
  • Strong verbal and written communication skills and excellent interpersonal abilities.
  • Detail-oriented, with strong analytical, problem-solving, and decision-making skills.
  • Proficient in Microsoft products and other technical tools relevant to the role.
  • Self-starter able to think strategically, work independently, and demonstrate initiative.
  • Team-oriented, positive, and collaborative attitude.
  • Ability to identify, research, and resolve problems and review materials for accuracy to summarize policies for customers.
  • Organized and professional, with passion for the insurance industry and commitment to continuous learning.

Nice To Haves

  • Life license.
  • Additional professional designations.

Responsibilities

  • Prospect and qualify new Personal Lines accounts that meet agency standards.
  • Generate new business appointments through networking, referrals, and other sources to attract and retain clients.
  • Identify cross-sell opportunities across departments and expand lines of business on current accounts.
  • Meet or exceed assigned annual new business revenue and retention goals.
  • Proactively manage an assigned book of business using the Epic Agency Management System.
  • Obtain information requested by company underwriters.
  • Partner with sales advisors in Personal Lines, Commercial Lines, and Employee Benefits to present personal insurance as a voluntary benefit to employees of current clients and prospects, including on-site marketing and quoting and presentations of personal insurance products.
  • Review new and renewal policies for accuracy in rating, typing, endorsement forms, and coverage.
  • Develop and maintain strong client relationships, support and educate clients on coverage and needs, and identify potential coverage gaps.
  • Act as a claims advocate in coordination with Agency Claims resources when applicable.
  • Adhere to standardized workflow procedures and report daily activities to the Team Lead of assigned branch(es).
  • Service Personal Lines accounts to eliminate coverage gaps and reduce E&O exposures.
  • Provide prompt, accurate, and courteous service to customers, producers, and company personnel.
  • Attend and participate in agency sales and service meetings and trainings.
  • Grow and develop insurance knowledge and professional talents in accordance with The Ansay Way.
  • Pursue continuous professional development, stay current with industry and carrier changes, participate in ongoing training, and pursue professional designations.
  • Perform additional duties as assigned.

Benefits

  • Competitive compensation.
  • Medical insurance.
  • Dental insurance.
  • Vision insurance.
  • 401(k) with company match.
  • Paid time off.
  • Paid holidays.
  • Professional development and designation support.
  • Career growth opportunities.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service