Underwriting Supervisor - Remote

Selective Insurance Company of America•UNAVAILABLE, UNAVAILABLE
•Remote

About The Position

Selective Insurance is hiring an Underwriting Supervisor to supervise underwriters and coordinate their work with internal and external personnel. The role operates within the letter of authority for referral underwriting and is responsible for a multi-jurisdiction underwriting team’s work quality, production, and profitability. The supervisor manages workflow and deadlines, provides technical guidance to underwriters and support to agents and policyholders, and coordinates with other supervisors, branches, and corporate departments. The position also involves staff development, process improvements, agency and regional relationship-building, and occasional participation in legal proceedings related to claims or coverage.

Requirements

  • Broad underwriting technical background.
  • Strong verbal and written communication skills.
  • Good analytical skills.
  • Proficiency with Word, Excel, and Outlook.
  • At least 7 years of underwriting experience.

Nice To Haves

  • College degree preferred.
  • 3–4 years of experience in rating, inspections, and claims preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Supervise, coordinate, and monitor a multi-jurisdiction underwriting team to ensure accurate, quality work and strong production.
  • Schedule, prioritize, and distribute unit workflow to complete work on time and meet deadlines.
  • Guide agents and policyholders and provide technical expertise to underwriters.
  • Liaise with other supervisors, branches, and corporate departments; conduct agency visits as required by company standards.
  • Recommend, plan, organize, and implement procedural changes, and stay current on changes affecting unit production and the insurance industry.
  • Manage the team's profitability and production in accordance with budget.
  • Arbitrate problems involving agents, insureds, or other departments.
  • Testify in court or participate in depositions as needed on claims or coverage issues.
  • Develop and use management reports to monitor team and individual underwriter results.
  • Travel to regions and visit agents and prospective agents to build relationships, increase awareness of service center services, and explore mutually beneficial opportunities; travel takes 5%–15% of employees’ time.
  • Oversee staff training and development, evaluate staff abilities and duties, provide ongoing guidance, and make personnel recommendations.

Benefits

  • Comprehensive health care plans.
  • Retirement savings plan with company match.
  • Discounted Employee Stock Purchase Program.
  • Tuition assistance and reimbursement programs.
  • 20 days of paid time off.
  • Competitive base salary.
  • Incentive plan eligibility at all levels.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service