Total Rewards Manager

Caritas Family Solutions•Belleville, IL

About The Position

The Total Rewards Manager shapes and manages Caritas Family Solutions’ Total Rewards portfolio, including compensation, benefits, leave administration, retirement plans, recognition programs, and employee engagement initiatives. This strategic and hands-on role develops competitive, cost-effective solutions to attract and retain high-performing team members while supporting organizational growth and culture. The manager is the primary resource for employees and external partners on compensation and benefits programs and leads related communications, policy development, compliance, and implementation. The role is in the People and Culture department, is exempt and full-time, and reports to the Director of People and Culture. Starting compensation is $65,000 annually. The position requires a bachelor’s degree in a relevant field and at least five years of progressive Human Resources experience with direct responsibility for compensation, benefits, or Total Rewards programs. A master’s degree and relevant professional certifications are preferred.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree in Human Resources, Business Administration, Finance, Organizational Development, or a related field.
  • Five or more years of progressive Human Resources experience with direct responsibility for compensation, benefits, or Total Rewards programs.
  • Experience analyzing compensation market data and administering employee benefit programs.
  • Experience developing employee communications and managing vendor relationships.
  • Knowledge of compensation strategy, pay equity, market benchmarking, employee benefits, leave management, retirement plan administration, HR compliance, employment law, vendor management, employee engagement, HRIS systems, reporting, workforce analytics, policy development, communication, and change management.
  • Strong written communication, organizational, analytical, and project management skills, including the ability to manage multiple priorities and deadlines.
  • Ability to lead strategic Total Rewards initiatives, influence organizational decisions, manage vendor relationships, and implement programs while balancing employee needs and organizational objectives.
  • Ability to build collaborative relationships with employees, department leaders, executive leadership, consultants, and benefit providers, and explain complex compensation and benefits concepts clearly.
  • Ability to evaluate complex compensation and benefits issues, identify practical solutions, make sound decisions, assess trends, and develop data-driven recommendations.
  • Proficiency with Microsoft Office Suite, including Excel, Word, PowerPoint, and Outlook, as well as HRIS, benefits administration platforms, payroll systems, reporting tools, and data analytics applications.
  • Expert computer skills in Excel, Outlook, HRIS, benefits administration platforms, payroll systems, reporting tools, and data analytics applications.
  • Technical knowledge of compensation analysis, salary administration, benefits and leave management, retirement plan administration, regulatory compliance, policy development, workforce analytics, and HRIS systems.
  • Ability to manage Total Rewards resources, including compensation budgets, benefits programs, retirement plans, leave processes, and vendor partnerships, while balancing organizational objectives with employee needs and ensuring cost-effective, compliant programs.
  • Willingness to adopt trauma-informed interventions, principles, and practices and commitment to ongoing professional development in trauma-informed care.
  • Required access to reliable transportation.
  • Valid driver’s license required.

Nice To Haves

  • Master’s degree in Human Resources, Business Administration, Organizational Leadership, or a related field.
  • Experience leading Total Rewards programs within a multi-site organization.
  • Experience in nonprofit or healthcare-related organizations.
  • Experience managing compensation planning cycles and pay equity initiatives.
  • Certified Compensation Professional (CCP).
  • SHRM-CP, SHRM-SCP, PHR, or SPHR certification.
  • Certified Benefits Professional (CBP).
  • Access to a reliable automobile.
  • Proof of continued auto insurance.

Responsibilities

  • Lead employee communications about Total Rewards programs, including annual benefits enrollment, employee recognition campaigns, attraction initiatives, and engagement resources.
  • Manage the development, implementation, evaluation, and enhancement of compensation and benefits strategies.
  • Collaborate with external compensation and benefits consultants to analyze market trends and benchmarks and develop competitive, cost-effective offerings.
  • Ensure compliance with federal, state, and local laws and regulations related to compensation, benefits, retirement plans, and leave administration.
  • Develop, maintain, communicate, and monitor Total Rewards policies and procedures across the organization.
  • Oversee leave programs, including FMLA, Workers’ Compensation, parental leave, short-term disability, and long-term disability.
  • Lead annual compensation planning and adjustments, including market benchmarking, pay equity analysis, merit planning, and implementation support.
  • Partner with Human Resources leadership, Talent Acquisition, and HR Business Partners to develop compensation strategies that support recruitment and retention.
  • Manage administration and compliance for the organization’s 403(b) retirement plan, including enrollments, payroll deductions, notices, and required communications.
  • Design, implement, and manage employee recognition and service award programs.
  • Develop written content, presentations, policies, website content, and other communications related to Total Rewards programs.
  • Maintain vendor relationships and oversee external benefits, retirement, compensation, and leave management partners.
  • Perform other duties as assigned.

Benefits

  • Generous paid time off.
  • Paid training.
  • Health insurance.
  • Dental and vision coverage.
  • Life insurance.
  • 403(b) retirement plan with a 5% company contribution.
  • Tuition reimbursement.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service