Sr Panel Strategic Relationship Manager

Hanover Insurance Group•Itasca, IL
•Hybrid

About The Position

The Sr Panel Strategic Relationship Manager provides strategic leadership and oversight of Hanover’s outside counsel panel, ensuring alignment with litigation strategy, business priorities, and operational goals. The role partners with Claims and legal leadership to guide panel governance, firm engagement, and performance management. Through data, insights, and cross-functional collaboration, the manager drives consistency, efficiency, and value in the organization’s use of outside counsel. The position supports panel strategy, firm selection, portfolio planning, performance assessment, and enterprise initiatives. It manages relationships with enterprise-level firms and complex litigation portfolios; provides guidance on panel operations, billing practices, rates, and litigation-guideline compliance; and facilitates stewardship meetings with firms and internal Claims stakeholders. The role also mentors peers and influences cross-functional partners as a senior subject-matter expert. The manager reviews enterprise analytics, works with analytics and IT teams to improve reporting, evaluates firm performance, recommends data-informed rate adjustments, and maintains data integrity. Additional responsibilities include leading legal quality audits, negotiating rates, identifying cost savings, coordinating critical law firm transitions, supporting outside counsel processes and billing guidelines, and recommending process improvements and potential firm additions.

Requirements

  • Juris Doctor (JD).
  • 8–10+ years of experience in litigation, insurance claims, legal operations, billing oversight, or panel counsel management.
  • Deep understanding of litigation strategy, insurance defense operations, and law firm performance dynamics.
  • Strong analytical capability, including experience with large datasets, performance dashboards, and enterprise reporting tools.
  • Ability to manage complex escalations, negotiate effectively, and maintain strong professional relationships.
  • Exceptional communication skills, particularly in high-stakes or conflicting-viewpoint environments.
  • Demonstrated ability to lead without direct authority, influence cross-functional teams, and serve as a senior advisor.
  • Strong project-management and process-improvement skills, including experience supporting transformational initiatives.
  • Effective time management and ability to balance competing priorities in a dynamic environment.
  • Ability to use a personal computer and other standard office equipment.
  • Ability to sit and/or stand for extended periods.
  • Ability to work on-site as needed.
  • Ability to work in a fast-paced, changing, or stressful environment.

Responsibilities

  • Support implementation of panel counsel strategies established by the VP of Claims Panel Management.
  • Provide insights and judgment for enterprise panel strategy, firm selection, and long-term portfolio planning.
  • Participate in strategic initiatives and enterprise projects, making data-backed recommendations on litigation trends, operational risk, and firm performance.
  • Assess law firm performance against expectations and provide actionable recommendations for continuous improvement.
  • Manage a portfolio of enterprise-level firms and high-complexity litigation, ensuring performance, strategic fit, and alignment with business objectives.
  • Provide guidance on panel counsel operations, billing practices, rate structures, and compliance with litigation guidelines.
  • Contribute to developing and standardizing program processes, tools, and performance-management approaches.
  • Facilitate stewardship meetings with portfolio firms and internal Claims stakeholders.
  • Mentor, train, and support peers and contribute to onboarding and thought leadership.
  • Influence cross-functional partners and model best practices in vendor management, legal quality assessment, strategic thinking, and collaboration.
  • Review enterprise analytics, interpret trends, and collaborate with analytics and IT teams to enhance reporting and decision-making.
  • Use reporting tools to evaluate firm performance and recommend rate adjustments based on data.
  • Ensure data integrity and accuracy, guide analytics-process enhancements, and translate findings into actionable recommendations.
  • Lead legal quality audits of panel firms to assess performance, compliance, and strategic alignment.
  • Negotiate rates and identify cost-saving measures while ensuring fiscal discipline and adherence to enterprise guidelines.
  • Coordinate enterprise-critical law firm transitions and support integration with claims systems, billing platforms, and operational workflows.
  • Support the development, implementation, and enforcement of outside counsel processes, tools, and billing guidelines.
  • Identify litigation trends and recommend process improvements to meet changing business needs and optimize outcomes.
  • Respond to internal requests and evaluate potential firm additions based on strategic fit, performance history, and business needs.

Benefits

  • Flexible hybrid work model supporting a blend of in-office and remote work.
  • Fully remote work arrangements are also considered.

Stand Out From the Crowd

Upload your resume and get instant feedback on how well it matches this job.

Upload and Match Resume

What This Job Offers

Job Type

Full-time

Career Level

Senior

Education Level

Ph.D. or professional degree

© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service