Settlement Negotiator

Finch LegalNew York, NY
$60,000 - $75,000Onsite

About The Position

About Finch We believe every American household deserves access to counsel in life’s biggest moments. At Finch, we’re building the infrastructure to make justice radically more accessible. Our modern approach to consumer law automates the admin work and puts clients first, starting with personal injury. In just over a year, we've grown 10x, raised a $20M Series A, and become the pre-litigation partner of choice for top personal injury firms across the country. We believe the best outcomes happen when expert operators and purpose-built AI work together – which is why we handle every step of pre-lit, from intake and claim opening to medical records, lien management, and demands, with humans leading every case. We’re backed by Sequoia, Redpoint, and the founders & CEOs of generational companies like DoorDash, Ironclad, and Digits. We’re rebuilding how the law serves everyday Americans from first principles, and we’re hiring exceptional operators to help us scale it nationwide. This Role Negotiators own the settlement and lien phase of every case. You'll work both sides of the recovery: negotiating bodily injury settlements with insurance carriers and reducing liens with subrogation vendors, healthcare plans, Medicare/Medicaid, and ERISA plans, so injured clients are made whole and attorneys can settle files quickly and effectively.

Requirements

  • 2+ years in PI lien or settlement negotiation, BI adjusting, or paralegal work
  • Coordinated lien resolution directly with subrogation companies (Medicare/Medicaid, ERISA, and health-plan vendors)
  • Maniacal sense of urgency and extreme ownership by chasing the answer rather than waiting for it
  • Highly organized and can juggle dozens of competing deadlines and SLAs
  • Comfortable with AI tools and concepts

Responsibilities

  • Negotiate bodily injury settlements with insurance carriers and adjusters, pushing for the strongest outcome on every file
  • Reduce and resolve medical liens
  • Build settlement breakdowns that reconcile gross recovery against fees, costs, and liens
  • Coordinate directly between carriers and subrogation companies, owning the back-and-forth
  • Carry a high volume of files, deadlines, and SLAs at once and follow up relentlessly when the other side goes quiet

Benefits

  • 100% coverage for health, dental, and vision
  • 401(k) retirement plan
  • In-office snacks, drinks, and daily team lunch and dinners
  • Flexible PTO (we trust you to take the time you need)
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service