Senior Underwriter, Primary Casualty

BP&C•New York City, NY
•Onsite

About The Position

Argo Group is seeking a Senior Underwriter for a production underwriting position responsible for marketing, underwriting, and processing assigned lines of business. Responsibilities may also include participating in special projects and mentoring less experienced staff. This is a 100% in-office position; the employee must work onsite at a designated company office during standard business hours. The role requires approximately 20% travel. The position is responsible for underwriting new business and renewal submissions, developing broker relationships and business opportunities, and meeting production and business-mix objectives. The NYC base salary range is $113,000–$165,000, commensurate with candidate experience. The position is also eligible for an annual bonus based on company and individual performance and a benefits package. Applicants must be legally authorized to work in the United States; employment visa sponsorship is not available.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree from an accredited university, or an equivalent combination of experience and education.
  • At least five years of underwriting experience with authority.
  • Demonstrated productive relationships with professional liability specialist brokers in the Central U.S. marketplace.
  • Strong negotiation skills and ability to achieve favorable, win-win outcomes.
  • Flexibility and ability to thrive amid change.
  • Strong execution and follow-through, with a proven ability to consistently deliver expected results.
  • Ability to collect, gather, manipulate, and analyze detailed information to draw conclusions about profitable underwriting.
  • Advanced knowledge of Excel, Outlook, and Word.
  • Ability to travel approximately 20% of the time.
  • Legally authorized to work in the United States; employment visa sponsorship is not available.

Nice To Haves

  • Previous insurance education; IIA and CPCU designations are strongly preferred.
  • Desire to continually update skills through continuing education and self-development.
  • Genuine excitement about meeting and exceeding customer expectations.

Responsibilities

  • Underwrite and analyze new business and renewal submissions for the assigned area.
  • Ensure marketing initiatives are achieved and communicate products and services consistently to retail and wholesale brokers.
  • Develop existing broker relationships and establish new relationships in targeted territories to attract business opportunities.
  • Participate actively in client and broker meetings.
  • Develop and maintain a submission pipeline sufficient to achieve overall production and business-mix objectives.
  • Use market contacts to bring in business, gather and share market intelligence, and cross-sell other products.
  • Participate in special projects and mentor less experienced staff, as needed.

Benefits

  • Annual bonus based on company and individual performance.
  • Health insurance.
  • Dental insurance.
  • Vision insurance.
  • 401(k) with company match.
  • Paid time off.
  • Professional development opportunities.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service