Senior Supervisor, PSA Customer Care

Collaborative SolutionsSanta Ana, CA
Onsite

About The Position

Collectors is seeking a Senior Supervisor, PSA Customer Care to drive the operational strategy of the customer experience, with a focus on enhancing and delivering exceptional customer service at scale. This role involves leading the day-to-day efforts of Customer Care Representatives, servicing the business needs of the PSA division. The ideal candidate is a people manager passionate about creating great experiences where brands and customers meet to drive growth. The Senior Supervisor will guide their team through periods of heightened demand, providing mentorship and direction. This position requires a blend of experience across operations, customer service, and leadership, with a hands-on and data-driven approach. The role reports to the Director, PSA Customer Care and is an onsite position in Santa Ana, CA.

Requirements

  • 7+ years of customer service-related experience
  • 3+ years supervising a customer service or call center team in a service-based business
  • A bachelor’s or Associate’s degree or equivalent working experience is highly preferred
  • Proven track record of implementing process improvements and standard operating procedures (SOPs) to drive consistency, increased speed, and quality of customer care delivery at scale
  • Demonstrated success supervising a team, with both a willingness and ability to drive influence and facilitate change
  • Proven supervisory abilities and skilled at making forward-thinking decisions to motivate and build effective teams to maximize performance and effect organizational change
  • Clear and professional oral and written communication skills in both positive and negative situations
  • Ability to diffuse conflict, maintain confidentiality, listen to others without interrupting, keep emotions under control, remain open to ideas, and try new things
  • Experience with Salesforce or a similar CRM; implementation experience is a plus
  • Familiarity with collectibles and the trading card hobby is a plus

Nice To Haves

  • Implementation experience with Salesforce or a similar CRM is a plus
  • Familiarity with collectibles and the trading card hobby is a plus

Responsibilities

  • Help define and implement operational and customer care representative team KPIs for the delivery of excellent and timely customer support services
  • Use data to drive decisions and operational changes
  • Ensure the PSA Customer Care Representative team is staffed to support customer service business growth
  • Implement and drive continuous improvement to Customer Care Representative training and onboarding
  • Partner with the Customer Care Manager to collaborate in designing and delivering a seamless customer experience strategy supported by data, brand insights, and technology, to deliver on a customer service experience that is streamlined, optimized, and personalized to the ‘collector’ experience
  • Be accountable for driving customer satisfaction and for ensuring levels are maintained in line with our company's service standards
  • Directly manage a team of agents, fostering a positive environment while promoting growth, accountability, and performance
  • Balance the needs of the customers, agents, and the company to ensure success for all

Benefits

  • Medical Insurance
  • Dental Insurance
  • Vision Insurance
  • Fertility benefits
  • Commuter benefits
  • Educational assistance benefits
  • 401(K) Matching Plan
  • Flexible time-off
  • Ten company paid holidays
  • Employee Discounts on select grading services
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service