Senior Coverage Litigation Counsel (Remote)

Selective Insurance Company of America•Short Hills, NJ
•Remote

About The Position

Provide timely and appropriate legal advice and opinions about coverage under Selective’s insurance policies, assist with day-to-day management of the Coverage unit within the Legal Department, and manage outside counsel as appropriate. Collaborate with the Legal and Compliance team, Claims, and outside counsel, while carrying out all responsibilities in compliance with applicable legal and regulatory requirements. The role manages complex coverage and litigation matters from inception through resolution, providing strategic oversight of high-exposure disputes, directing outside counsel, and advising business partners on litigation risk. It advises Claims on policy application and compliance, reservations of rights and declination letters, declaratory judgment actions, coverage litigation, the duty to defend, and related indemnification claims. The role assesses and resolves complex legal and coverage issues while protecting Selective’s financial and strategic interests and communicating relevant issues to senior leadership. The position monitors state and federal court decisions on coverage issues to inform claims coverage analysis, claims handling practices, and underwriting coverage grants. It oversees the correspondence forms library, leads internal training on coverage litigation topics, advises on panel counsel selection, collaborates on maintaining the approved coverage counsel list, provides training to Claims and Underwriting when requested, and reviews and improves litigation protocols. The position fosters collaboration and communication in support of departmental and enterprise goals.

Requirements

  • Juris Doctor (JD).
  • At least 6 years of litigation experience, preferably in insurance coverage.
  • Licensed to practice law in at least one U.S. jurisdiction.
  • Deep expertise in property and casualty insurance and coverage legal issues.
  • Ability to process information quickly and propose workable solutions.
  • Strong written and verbal communication skills, including the ability to explain complex legal concepts clearly to non-lawyers.
  • Excellent analytical skills and judgment, with strategic thinking ability.
  • Proven track record of earning and keeping the trust of clients and colleagues.
  • Ability to manage high-profile cases and stakeholders.
  • Proven track record of successful litigation outcomes.

Nice To Haves

  • Insurance coverage litigation experience is preferred.
  • Admission in New Jersey or New York is preferred.
  • Eligibility for a New Jersey in-house counsel limited license is preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Manage complex coverage and litigation matters from inception through resolution.
  • Provide strategic oversight of high-exposure disputes, direct outside counsel, and advise business partners on litigation risk.
  • Provide legal advice, counsel, and opinions to Claims on coverage issues, including policy application, reservations of rights and declination letters, and the appropriateness of declaratory judgment actions.
  • Assess, communicate, and resolve complex legal and coverage issues while protecting the organization’s financial and strategic interests; communicate these issues to senior leadership and management.
  • Advise on the defense, management, and resolution of coverage litigation.
  • Monitor state and federal court decisions on coverage issues and advise on claims coverage analysis, claims handling practices, and underwriting coverage grants.
  • Advise on the duty to defend insureds and putative additional insureds and related indemnification claims.
  • Manage the correspondence forms library to ensure Claims communications are understandable and meet policy and regulatory requirements while enhancing the customer experience.
  • Lead internal training on coverage litigation topics and provide training to Claims and Underwriting on legal matters when requested.
  • Advise on panel counsel selection for defense, coverage, and extracontractual matters.
  • Collaborate with the Senior Coverage Counsel, Claims Legal Administrator, and Compliance Officer to maintain the approved coverage counsel list.
  • Foster collaboration, partnership, and communication to achieve departmental and enterprise goals.
  • Review and improve litigation protocols.

Benefits

  • Competitive base salary
  • Incentive plan eligibility at all levels
  • Comprehensive health care plans
  • Retirement savings plan with company match
  • Discounted Employee Stock Purchase Program
  • Tuition assistance and reimbursement programs
  • 20 days of paid time off

Stand Out From the Crowd

Upload your resume and get instant feedback on how well it matches this job.

Upload and Match Resume

What This Job Offers

Job Type

Full-time

Career Level

Senior

Education Level

Ph.D. or professional degree

© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service