Senior Claims Specialist - Subrogation

Utica National Insurance GroupNew Hartford, NY
Onsite

About The Position

The Senior Claims Specialist - Auto & Property Subrogation will be responsible for pursuit of liable entities through a variety of avenues, including Arbitration Forums, E-Subro Hub, Restitution, Collections Vendors, Litigation, Installment Agreements, etc. The Specialist will collaborate with assigned claim handlers to investigate & resolve cases in a timely manner. Contribute to decision making as an Arbitration Panelist through Arbitration Forums.

Requirements

  • 4-year degree or equivalent experience.
  • At least 2 years as a Claims and/or Subrogation Specialist required.
  • Licensing Required to obtain your license(s) as an adjuster in the state(s) in which you are assigned to adjust claims.
  • Licensing must be obtained within the timeframe set forth by the Company and must be maintained as needed throughout your employment.

Nice To Haves

  • Prior experience with Arbitration and/or Litigation preferred.
  • Property experience is a plus, but not required.

Responsibilities

  • Identify and pursue all potential avenues of recovery on any viable claim.
  • Investigate and review all claim activity, and if necessary, direct non-injury or bodily injury representative to obtain additional evidence to finalize & determine Founders coverage and/or liability position.
  • Gather payments, supports, data, and other relevant materials in support of any subrogation claim.
  • Pursue subrogation recovery from all appropriate parties who are legal liable for damages via Arbitration Forums, Collections Agencies, Litigation and/or Court Restitution.
  • Adjust, negotiate, and settle subrogation claims in a prompt manner.
  • Request Authority for settlement as warranted.
  • Attend settlement conferences, mediations, and/or Arbitrations as mandated by the courts in cases involving Litigation.
  • Consult direct supervisor on all decisions which require waiver of subrogation rights and pursuit.
  • Request checks in settlement of subrogation claims and in satisfaction of Arbitration Forum decisions.
  • Maintain a strict diary on all active files.
  • Document clear and specific notes in the claim file for all active subrogation claims.
  • Attend training to be proficient in all claim systems to assist other division(s) as warranted.
  • Attend training to become a Certified Arbitrator through Arbitration Forums, hear cases as a panelist
  • Performs other duties as assigned.
  • Conforms with all corporate policies and procedures.
  • Broad knowledge and understanding of the law and claim practices.
  • Reviewing court decisions, law and coverage interpretations.
  • May assume duties of the Claims Supervisor in the Supervisor’s absence.

Benefits

  • Medical and Prescription Drug Benefit
  • Dental Benefit
  • Vision Benefit
  • Life Insurance and Disability Benefits
  • 401(k) Profit Sharing and Investment Plan (Includes annual Company financial contribution and discretionary Profit Sharing contribution based upon annual company financial results)
  • Health Savings Account (HSA)
  • Flexible Spending Accounts
  • Tuition Assistance, Training, and Professional Designations
  • Company-Paid Family Leave
  • Adoption/Surrogacy Assistance Benefit
  • Voluntary Benefits - Group Accident Insurance, Hospital Indemnity, Critical Illness, Legal, ID Theft Protection, Pet Insurance
  • Student Loan Refinancing Services
  • Care.com Membership with Back-up Care, Senior Solutions
  • Business Travel Accident Insurance
  • Matching Gifts program
  • Paid Volunteer Day
  • Employee Referral Award Program
  • Wellness programs
  • Personal insurance discount
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service