Senior Claim Specialist, Casualty Claims

Vantage Risk•Chicago, IL
•Remote

About The Position

At Vantage, the Senior Claim Specialist, Casualty Claims is a critical member of the Casualty team, whose mission is to combine creativity with tech-enabled efficiency and robust analytics to address risks others avoid. The role provides complete claim management and loss mitigation services for policyholders on a dedicated account basis. It independently investigates, evaluates, and manages the disposition of Primary and Excess Casualty claims of varying complexity and severity across multiple product types and markets. The position also supports Underwriting Business Units by liaising with account and broker/agent representatives, providing frequent, in-depth exposure analysis to senior leadership, and participating in marketing efforts at industry events and conferences. The role reports to the AVP, Casualty Claims and is a remote work opportunity. The stated base salary expectation is $115,000 to $140,000; actual base salary may be higher depending on the selected candidate’s experience and expectations. Vantage offers performance-based bonus potential, health and welfare benefits, retirement plans with company match, competitive time-off plans, and a highly flexible work environment.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree or equivalent professional experience.
  • At least six years of end-to-end direct handling experience in Casualty claims.
  • Experience handling Primary Casualty claims, including premises-based general liability and hired/non-owned auto claims.
  • Experience handling Umbrella and Excess Casualty claims, including trucking, habitational, hospitality, and construction casualty claims.
  • Strong knowledge of complex Casualty risks.
  • Strong problem-solving and negotiation skills.
  • Excellent communication and interpersonal relationship-building skills.
  • Ability to work independently, identify and solve issues, and recognize when to escalate them.
  • Ability to thrive in a dynamic, team-focused environment and deliver on tight deadlines.
  • Analytical ability to identify and define problems, extract key information from data, and develop workable solutions.
  • Accountability, organization, prioritization, action orientation, goal-setting, resilience, and a focus on delivering results.
  • Customer-service focus: ability to recognize customer needs, meet requirements, and add value while balancing service with business imperatives.
  • Digital savvy and insight: ability to gather information from varied sources, cut through complexity, consider options, solve problems, and make decisions.
  • Strong knowledge of Microsoft Word, Excel, and PowerPoint.
  • Respectful and collegial approach to internal and external stakeholders and business partners.

Nice To Haves

  • Juris Doctorate degree.
  • Familiarity with Claude and its use in a claims environment.

Responsibilities

  • Independently investigate, evaluate, and manage Primary and Excess Casualty claims of varying complexity and severity across multiple product types and markets.
  • Provide complete claim management and loss mitigation services for policyholders on a dedicated account basis.
  • Evaluate, reserve, and manage casualty claims to resolution, including overseeing all phases of litigation related to Casualty exposures.
  • Review coverage, draft coverage letters, and communicate coverage positions to insureds, brokers, and agents as necessary.
  • Communicate regularly with insureds, brokers, and internal and external stakeholders about individual claim development and strategy.
  • Provide superior customer service and build strong relationships with assigned-account representatives, including internal leadership, brokers, and agents.
  • Follow Vantage Claims Best Practices and applicable compliance requirements, and manage retained counsel to drive efficient, proactive litigation defense strategies.
  • Document claim files thoroughly and clearly with relevant factual and evaluative information in compliance with company policies, best practices, and applicable regulatory authority where necessary.
  • Use subject-matter knowledge and negotiation skills to achieve appropriate claim outcomes through direct negotiation and alternative dispute resolution as necessary.
  • Proactively drive claim development and seek creative ways to achieve optimal results on every file.
  • Follow Vantage’s reserving and reporting protocols to avoid unexpected developments and outcomes.
  • Identify issues and trends within assigned accounts and the Financial Institutions market, and communicate them to insureds, Vantage Claims leadership, Underwriting partners, and actuaries.
  • Follow escalation and reporting protocols for cases with significant potential exposure.
  • Attend marketing, account renewal, and reinsurance meetings as appropriate to communicate Vantage’s claims handling philosophy and value proposition.
  • Support Underwriting Business Units by liaising with account and broker/agent representatives and providing exposure analysis to senior leadership.
  • Participate in marketing efforts at industry events and conferences.
  • Treat internal and external stakeholders and business partners respectfully and maintain a positive, collegial approach.

Benefits

  • Performance-based bonus potential.
  • Health and welfare benefits.
  • Retirement plans with company match.
  • Competitive time-off plans.
  • Highly flexible work environment.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service