Senior Claim Examiner I

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc.•Princeton, NJ

About The Position

The Senior Claim Examiner manages complex and high-exposure workers’ compensation claims from start to resolution. The role involves investigating claims, determining compensability, setting reserves, and negotiating settlements. The Senior Claim Examiner also serves as a resource for junior examiners and assists with mentoring. The position is part of the Workers’ Compensation team and contributes to compliant claim handling and service. Responsibilities include communicating with injured workers, medical providers, and employer representatives; evaluating treatment and medical bills; arranging timely payments; responding to claim-status questions; and consulting with attorneys on litigation management, settlement strategy, and claim resolution.

Requirements

  • At least 5 years of workers’ compensation claims experience.
  • Strong technical knowledge of workers’ compensation claims.
  • Experience with MS Office, including Word, Excel, and Outlook.
  • Effective negotiation skills.
  • Strong verbal and written communication skills.
  • Ability to prioritize workload to meet deadlines.
  • Ability to manage multiple tasks in a fast-paced environment.

Responsibilities

  • Manage complex and high-exposure workers’ compensation claims from start to resolution.
  • Investigate claims, determine compensability, set reserves, and negotiate settlements.
  • Serve as a resource for junior examiners and assist with mentoring.
  • Thoroughly investigate workers’ compensation claims by contacting injured workers, medical providers, and employer representatives.
  • Determine whether claims are valid under applicable workers’ compensation statutes.
  • Communicate with medical providers to develop and authorize appropriate treatment plans.
  • Review and analyze medical bills to confirm charges and treatment are related to the workers’ compensation injury and follow the treatment plan.
  • Ensure medical bill and income-replacement payments are remitted timely in accordance with applicable fee schedules and statutes.
  • Answer questions from claimants, policyholders, and medical providers regarding pending claim status.
  • Consult with attorneys regarding litigation management, settlement strategy, and claim resolution.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service