Program Manager Payment Integrity

Medica•St. Louis, MO
•$78,700 - $118,020•Hybrid

About The Position

The Program Manager – Payment Integrity supports the end-to-end management, performance, and optimization of Payment Integrity programs and capabilities. The role provides structure, visibility, and accountability across initiatives, vendor relationships, financial performance, operational execution, and issue resolution. It connects program performance, financial outcomes, operational impacts, and execution to help ensure Payment Integrity investments deliver measurable value while supporting accurate and efficient claims payment. Other duties may be assigned. Two openings support either Internal Overpayment Recovery Process Operations or Vendor Relationships and Optimization. The position is an office role requiring onsite work an average of three days per week. Candidates may be located near the Minnetonka, Minnesota; Madison, Wisconsin; St. Louis, Missouri; or Omaha, Nebraska offices. Medica does not offer work visa sponsorship; candidates must be legally authorized to work in the United States at application, and employment is contingent on verification of identity and work eligibility.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree in business, healthcare administration, finance, operations, analytics, or a related field, or equivalent relevant professional experience.
  • At least 5 years of experience in Payment Integrity in a people, operational, or process leadership role.
  • Experience developing and documenting operational processes, workflows, governance models, and standard operating procedures in a healthcare or insurance environment.
  • Strong understanding of healthcare claims payment, overpayment recovery, reimbursement methodologies, and payment accuracy programs.

Nice To Haves

  • At least 2 years of direct Payment Integrity experience supporting overpayment recovery, claims auditing, payment accuracy programs, or healthcare cost containment initiatives.
  • Demonstrated success leading organizational enhancement efforts, including cross-functional program implementations.
  • Experience managing Payment Integrity vendors and strategic partner relationships, including performance monitoring, issue resolution, contract oversight, and implementation of new vendor solutions.
  • Experience leading cross-functional program implementations with partners such as Operations, Claims, Legal, Technology, Procurement, Security, and Finance.
  • Strong analytical and problem-solving skills, including the ability to identify root causes, remove operational barriers, and drive resolution across multiple stakeholders.
  • Proven ability to establish program structure during organizational change, transformation, or team growth, including building new processes and operational capabilities.

Responsibilities

  • Support the end-to-end lifecycle of Payment Integrity programs, including planning, implementation, operationalization, performance monitoring, optimization, and ongoing evaluation.
  • Establish program objectives, performance expectations, deliverables, dependencies, and success measures.
  • Coordinate activities across Payment Integrity, Claims Operations, Product, Technology, Configuration, Finance, Analytics, and other stakeholders.
  • Maintain visibility into program milestones, risks, decisions, dependencies, and outstanding actions.
  • Support implementation and operational readiness for new Payment Integrity capabilities, vendors, and program enhancements.
  • Ensure program activities align with broader Payment Integrity and Core Operations priorities.
  • Manage day-to-day business performance relationships with Payment Integrity vendors and strategic partners.
  • Monitor vendor performance against contractual commitments, service-level expectations, financial targets, quality measures, and operational outcomes.
  • Lead recurring vendor performance reviews and ensure accountability for actions and improvement opportunities.
  • Identify vendor performance gaps and coordinate corrective action plans through resolution.
  • Partner with Procurement, Finance, Legal, and business stakeholders on vendor performance, contract considerations, renewals, and strategic opportunities.
  • Partner with Finance, Analytics, and Payment Integrity leadership to establish and monitor program financial performance and return on investment.
  • Track program value, including identified and realized savings, recoveries, cost avoidance, vendor expenses, and other relevant financial measures.
  • Analyze actual performance against business cases, forecasts, targets, and contractual expectations; identify performance variance drivers and recommend ways to improve financial outcomes.
  • Support business cases and financial assessments for new capabilities, vendor solutions, program expansions, and strategic investments.
  • Provide leadership with visibility into investment value and areas where intervention or optimization may be required.
  • Develop and maintain Payment Integrity program scorecards, dashboards, and recurring performance reports.
  • Consolidate financial, operational, vendor, quality, and program information into a comprehensive view of program health.
  • Analyze trends and performance drivers to identify risks, opportunities, and areas requiring leadership attention.
  • Translate complex program information into executive-level insights, recommendations, and decision points.
  • Support recurring Payment Integrity business reviews, vendor reviews, operating reviews, and leadership discussions.
  • Identify opportunities to improve Payment Integrity performance, operational efficiency, vendor effectiveness, and financial outcomes.
  • Partner with Payment Integrity subject matter experts to evaluate opportunities for new edits, analytics, vendors, workflows, or capabilities.
  • Coordinate with Claims Operations and Configuration to understand downstream operational impacts and ensure changes are effectively implemented.
  • Partner with Product and Technology on system capabilities, integrations, defects, and enhancements affecting Payment Integrity programs.
  • Support prioritization with clear information on expected value, operational impact, risk, effort, and dependencies.
  • Facilitate stakeholder alignment and drive actions toward resolution when ownership spans multiple teams.

Benefits

  • Competitive medical coverage
  • Dental coverage
  • Vision coverage
  • Paid time off
  • Paid holidays
  • Paid volunteer time off
  • 401(k) contributions
  • Caregiver services
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service