Paralegal - First-Party Property

Hamilton & Miller, PA•Miami, FL

About The Position

The First-Party Property Paralegal provides litigation and discovery support to attorneys in the First-Party Property practice group. The role manages subpoenas and discovery workflows, reviews and analyzes records, identifies key facts, and coordinates with providers, vendors, and experts. It requires strong organization, initiative, and the ability to work independently in a defense-litigation setting. The paralegal drafts, serves, and responds to discovery and subpoenas; tracks deadlines and deficiencies; organizes and summarizes records; prepares medical chronologies; conducts research; drafts litigation and trial-preparation materials; manages calendars and scheduling; and supports e-filing and hearing or trial preparation. The role also coordinates with courts, clients, vendors, providers, experts, opposing counsel, court reporters, and interpreters. The position requires 3–5+ years of paralegal experience supporting a First-Party Property defense practice group. A paralegal certificate or equivalent combination of education and experience is required; a bachelor's degree is preferred. Trial-preparation exposure, an existing or developing network of experts and providers, and experience with the firm's or a similar case-management system are preferred.

Requirements

  • 3–5+ years of paralegal experience supporting a First-Party Property defense practice group.
  • Proven proficiency in defense First-Party Property discovery and subpoena practice.
  • Expertise reviewing medical records, preparing chronologies, and mapping providers; ability to identify gaps and issues requiring escalation.
  • Strong organization, time management, and attention to detail across multiple matters.
  • Professional written and verbal communication and effective stakeholder management.
  • Technical proficiency with LexisNexis or Westlaw and at least one records platform, such as Magna Record, Ontellus, or a comparable platform.
  • Comfort with case/document management systems and standard office software.
  • Resourcefulness, proactivity, and ability to work independently within established procedures.
  • Paralegal certificate or equivalent combination of education and experience.

Nice To Haves

  • Bachelor's degree.
  • Trial-preparation exposure, including exhibit lists, witness preparation, and trial notebooks.
  • An existing network of experts and providers or a defined plan to develop one.
  • Prior experience with the firm's or a similar case-management system.

Responsibilities

  • Draft, serve, and respond to discovery and subpoenas; track deadlines and deficiencies; maintain logs and ticklers.
  • Prepare and follow up on record and deposition subpoenas, including HIPAA compliance and chain of custody.
  • Intake, organize, and summarize records; create medical chronologies; identify gaps and flag issues such as prior injuries, pre-existing conditions, and causation.
  • Identify treating, referring, and anticipated providers; coordinate IMEs and expert engagement; prepare expert notebooks.
  • Conduct legal and factual research using LexisNexis or Westlaw.
  • Draft pleadings, discovery, subpoenas duces tecum, deposition summaries, and trial and pretrial materials.
  • Manage calendars and critical deadlines; schedule depositions, hearings, mediations, IMEs, and related travel.
  • Coordinate with courts, clients, vendors, providers, experts, and opposing counsel.
  • E-file in state and federal courts; prepare exhibit and hearing binders; coordinate court reporters and interpreters.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service