Level 2 Claims Manager

Amwins•Sunrise, FL
•Hybrid

About The Position

Amwins Specialty Auto is seeking an experienced, results-driven Level 2 Claims Manager (Bodily Injury) to lead a team of bodily injury claims professionals handling coverage analysis, liability assessment, negotiation, and resolution of represented and unrepresented claims on non-standard auto policies. The manager oversees day-to-day operations, supports sound indemnity and expense outcomes, and develops adjusters. The role is accountable for coverage and liability decisions, reserve and settlement quality, regulatory compliance, and team performance. It works closely with Level 1 managers, injury and material damage teams, SIU, subrogation, defense counsel, and company leadership. This is an in-office position in Plano, Texas, or Sunrise, Florida, with the option for a hybrid schedule after training is complete. Amwins Specialty Auto is part of Amwins Group, described as the largest specialty broker in the United States, with over $14 billion of premium.

Requirements

  • 5–7 years of bodily injury claims experience, including coverage analysis and liability evaluation; non-standard auto experience preferred.
  • Proven experience negotiating and resolving represented bodily injury claims.
  • Working knowledge of Texas, Oklahoma, and Florida claim-handling laws, including time-limit demands and extra-contractual exposure.
  • Must hold or be able to obtain a Florida and Texas adjuster license before the start date; other state licenses as required.
  • Strong judgment in guiding team members through complex, high-severity, or sensitive claims.
  • Excellent communication, coaching, and leadership skills.
  • Strong organizational and time-management skills.
  • Detail-oriented, with a commitment to accuracy and regulatory compliance.

Nice To Haves

  • At least 2 years of claims supervisory or lead experience.
  • Non-standard auto claims experience.
  • Bachelor’s degree or above.

Responsibilities

  • Lead a team of adjusters handling represented and unrepresented bodily injury claims.
  • Make coverage and liability decisions by reviewing policy language, endorsements, and exclusions, and issue reservation-of-rights and coverage-position letters as needed.
  • Review adjusters’ liability, comparative-fault, and damages evaluations for accuracy and support, and confirm decisions are well documented.
  • Direct negotiation strategy on represented claims, including policy-limit and time-limited demands; identify excess and bad-faith exposure early and escalate it.
  • Ensure prompt and fair handling of unrepresented claimants, including timely contact, clear communication, and appropriate release practices.
  • Grant and monitor settlement authority within assigned limits and escalate requests that exceed those limits.
  • Manage reserves for adequacy and timeliness throughout the life of each claim.
  • Identify and escalate suspected fraud, subrogation and recovery opportunities, and complex or high-severity claims.
  • Ensure compliance with company standards and state requirements, including claim-handling timelines, Medicare reporting, and regulatory complaints.
  • Hire, coach, and develop adjusters; conduct file audits, one-on-ones, and performance reviews.
  • Track and report team results, including indemnity and expense trends, cycle time, closing ratios, reserve accuracy, and quality scores.
  • Handle escalated insured, claimant, attorney, and agent concerns with clear explanations of decisions.
  • Foster a high-performing team culture focused on service excellence and continuous improvement.

Benefits

  • Medical, dental, and vision coverage available from the first day of employment.
  • Choice of medical plans through Blue Cross Blue Shield; Kaiser available for California employees.
  • Mental health support, including virtual therapy, digital coaching, and 24/7 EAP counseling.
  • Company-paid Basic Life and AD&D Insurance, Short-Term Disability, and Employee Assistance Program.
  • Health Savings Account with company contributions.
  • Health Care FSA, Dependent Care FSA, and commuter benefits.
  • Parental leave and adoption assistance.
  • Voluntary life insurance, critical illness, accident, and identity theft protection coverage options.
  • Retiree medical benefits available for Medicare-eligible retirees.
  • 401(k) with company match.
  • Generous paid time off and company holiday schedule.
  • Collaborative, continuing-education-focused work environment.
  • Career advancement opportunities.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service