AAA Insurance Sales Agent (Hybrid)

AAA Central Penn•Carlisle, PA
•Hybrid

About The Position

AAA Central Penn is seeking an experienced, results-driven Insurance Sales Agent to advise members and customers on personal lines insurance, build relationships, and generate sales. The role offers competitive hourly pay plus commission, with hybrid scheduling eligibility for high-performing, tenured professionals based on experience and results. Top Insurance Sales Agents averaged $100K in 2024. The position includes regular business travel and requires employees who drive for business to maintain a valid driver’s license, a satisfactory driving record, and insurance coverage that meets company requirements. Agents develop leads through AAA’s member base, walk-ins, phone, internet, and networking; maintain a prospect pipeline; and meet activity and sales goals. They quote and sell personal lines products, educate customers, identify cross-selling opportunities, and partner with Client Service Agents on complex service needs. Agents must comply with applicable requirements and protect customer confidentiality.

Requirements

  • High school diploma or equivalent.
  • At least 3 years of proven success in the insurance industry.
  • Active Pennsylvania Property & Casualty and Life & Health licenses.
  • Strong sales mindset and a track record of achieving results.
  • Excellent communication skills and ability to build trust quickly.
  • Detail-oriented with a customer-first approach.
  • Employees who drive for business must maintain a valid driver’s license, a satisfactory driving record, and insurance coverage that meets company requirements.

Nice To Haves

  • Hybrid schedule eligibility is available to high-performing, tenured insurance professionals based on experience and results.

Responsibilities

  • Generate and develop leads through AAA’s member base, walk-ins, phone, internet, and networking.
  • Manage and actively maintain a pipeline of prospects.
  • Make at least 50 prospecting calls per week and track activity.
  • Meet or exceed key performance goals, including a 33% closing rate.
  • Quote and sell personal lines insurance products while educating customers.
  • Support complex service needs in partnership with Client Service Agents.
  • Ensure compliance and protect customer confidentiality.
  • Identify cross-sell opportunities across AAA products and services.
  • Travel regularly for business purposes.

Benefits

  • Competitive hourly rate plus opportunity for commission.
  • Hybrid schedule eligibility for proven performers.
  • Generous, front-loaded paid time off with no waiting period to use it.
  • One personal day and eight paid holidays, including Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve.
  • Medical, dental, and vision coverage.
  • Health Savings Account with employer contribution and Flexible Spending Accounts.
  • 401(k) with up to 6% company match and immediate vesting.
  • Company-paid life insurance and long-term disability.
  • Up to three additional PTO days for volunteering and AAA Cares events.
  • Tuition reimbursement.
  • Free AAA Premier Membership.
  • Exclusive discounts on travel, services, and more.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service