Insurance Sales Agent - Benefit Lines

Newtek One•,
•$70,000 - $75,000

About The Position

Newtek Insurance Agency is a retail and wholesale brokerage licensed in all 50 states, specializing in commercial and health/benefits insurance for small- and medium-sized businesses, as well as certain personal lines. The Insurance Sales Agent – Benefit Lines consults with prospects, closes new business, and helps expand the Benefit Lines client portfolio by working with regional vice presidents, alliance partners, and the Marketing team. Leads may come from internal cross-selling referrals and other referral sources. The role involves prospecting, qualifying and analyzing client coverage needs, recommending suitable solutions, selling and implementing group benefits, and managing opportunities from initial inquiry through placement. The agent maintains frequent client contact, accurate pipeline and referral records, production and revenue targets, and relationships with clients and business partners. The position also provides consultative guidance on ACA matters and coordinates with third-party administrators and internal teams on related documentation and compliance.

Requirements

  • Bachelor's degree or equivalent experience.
  • At least three years of experience in the insurance industry at a brokerage, large insurance agency, or carrier, with exposure to multiple lines of business.
  • Valid Life, Accident & Health Insurance License; a copy must be provided for the file.
  • Strong expertise in sales and implementation of group benefits, including medical, dental, vision, short- and long-term disability, life and AD&D, Aflac, FSA, HSA, and HRA.
  • Ability to calculate employee payroll deductions and work cross-functionally to support a positive customer experience.
  • Knowledge of insurance markets, their business models, and policy language, with the ability to explain coverage.
  • Excellent sales, negotiation, persuasion, and closing skills.
  • Ability to make 50–75 outbound calls per day and meet client talk-time targets.
  • Ability to manage multiple tasks and a fast-paced workload with urgency, accuracy, and attention to detail.
  • Ability to communicate clearly and concisely, both orally and in writing.
  • Excellent time management, planning, and organizational skills.
  • Ability to work independently and as part of a team, collaborate, cooperate, and share knowledge.
  • Strong work ethic, ownership, and commitment to client service.
  • Comfort appearing on video camera while engaging with clients and attending meetings as required.
  • Ability to distinguish agency-billed clients from direct-billed clients.

Nice To Haves

  • Experience with BenefitPoint.
  • Exposure to additional group benefit products and coverages, including ACA reporting, COBRA administration, FSA/HSA, and compliance products.
  • Knowledge of an Agency Management System.

Responsibilities

  • Contact incoming inquiries and internal customer referrals, prospect among existing clients, and reach out to alliance partners to generate new business.
  • Qualify prospects, assess coverage needs and risk exposures, and recommend appropriate insurance solutions.
  • Sell and implement medical, dental, vision, and other ancillary group benefit products for small and large groups.
  • Meet monthly production and revenue goals for booking and binding new business, and maintain management-established sales metrics and talk-time targets.
  • Contact each incoming referral the same day or by the next business day when received after 5 p.m. local time.
  • Follow up with clients every two to three days after initial contact and keep them informed throughout the sales process.
  • Maintain an approximately 110-opportunity open pipeline, own pipeline development, and keep Newtracker referrals updated with current activity and next steps.
  • Generate and distribute weekly new-business pipeline reports to management.
  • Use internal referral management systems to document sales progress and milestones accurately.
  • Educate prospects about available coverages, policy inclusions, limitations, and changes, including consultative guidance on ACA and its effects on small and large group employers.
  • Partner with third-party administrators and vendors on ACA reporting, COBRA administration, FSA, HSA, and related compliance documentation.
  • Develop and maintain relationships with clients, decision makers, RVPs, and alliance partners.
  • Obtain underwriting information and prepare applications and specifications for new and renewal business submissions.
  • Work with the Marketing team to quote policies and identify account-rounding opportunities.
  • Communicate quote terms, conditions, and timeline changes to clients and set clear expectations.
  • Secure placement subjectivities by obtaining signed documentation, collecting payment, and binding coverage with carriers.
  • Return phone calls and respond to emails in a timely manner.
  • Engage with clients for at least four hours per day on the phone and make 50–75 outbound calls per day.
  • Represent the company professionally in client interactions and meetings, including appearing on camera as required.

Benefits

  • Competitive salary
  • Performance-based bonus program
  • Medical, dental, and vision benefits
  • Supplemental benefits
  • 401(k) savings plan with employer match
  • Ongoing training on sales techniques, the industry, and the competitive landscape
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service