Retail Store Head Buyer

Monmouth Trading Cards•East Brunswick, NJ
•Onsite

About The Position

Monmouth Trading Cards is seeking an experienced, highly organized Head Buyer for its East Brunswick, New Jersey location. The role leads purchasing operations for trading cards and collectibles, including evaluating customer collections, negotiating purchases, and coordinating each acquisition from intake through packing and shipping. The Head Buyer works in a fast-paced collectibles environment and uses market knowledge and attention to detail to manage paperwork, inventory intake, and shipping logistics. The position works closely with retail and warehouse staff to transition acquired inventory into store displays or online sales channels. Success includes making consistent, profitable acquisitions through fair customer negotiations, maintaining complete and accurate transaction paperwork, shipping purchases securely and on schedule, and keeping intake and inventory organized and traceable.

Requirements

  • Strong organizational skills, including the ability to manage multiple purchases, detailed paperwork, and shipping schedules simultaneously.
  • Confident, persuasive, and personable communication and negotiation skills, with the ability to build trust while protecting company margins.
  • Deep knowledge of sports cards, trading card games such as Pokémon and Magic: The Gathering, card condition grading, and current market valuation tools.
  • Hands-on experience safely packing fragile or high-value collectibles and managing outbound shipping workflows on tight timelines.
  • High accuracy when handling cash or payouts, recording serial numbers or card lists, and processing intake forms.

Nice To Haves

  • Prior experience in buying, retail management, or the collectibles industry.

Responsibilities

  • Evaluate individual cards, sealed products, and full collections offered by customers.
  • Negotiate fair, profitable purchase prices while providing customers with a transparent and positive experience.
  • Complete, verify, and file purchase paperwork, intake logs, receipts, and compliance documentation.
  • Pack purchased collections and outbound shipments securely to protect high-value items and coordinate timely dispatch.
  • Track incoming purchases, sort inventory, and keep the buying station and storage areas clean and orderly.
  • Monitor trading card market trends, grading standards, and current pricing to inform buying decisions.
  • Collaborate with retail and warehouse staff to move purchased inventory into store displays or online sales channels.

Benefits

  • Employee discounts
  • Flexible schedule
  • Free food and snacks
  • Free uniforms
  • Health insurance
  • Opportunity for advancement
  • Training and development
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service