Garage Underwriter - Remote

Selective Insurance Company of America•UNAVAILABLE, UNAVAILABLE
•Remote

About The Position

Selective Insurance is seeking a Garage Underwriter to support business growth and profitability by underwriting garage risks within established authority and guidelines. The role reviews and processes submissions for automotive-related accounts, applying basic garage underwriting rules, rating manual requirements, and applicable laws and regulations. It also supports an assigned agency book of business and provides timely service and underwriting support to agents while developing foundational knowledge of garage operations, coverages, and risk exposures. The position processes and triages submissions, applies eligibility and underwriting guidelines to routine garage classes, performs standard pricing and rating tasks under limited authority, and completes underwriting system transactions and documentation. It supports quotes, renewals, endorsements, and routine policy changes; communicates with agents about status, documentation needs, and basic process or coverage questions; and escalates complex or out-of-authority matters. The role also tracks submission outcomes, collaborates with underwriting and operations colleagues, follows compliance and recordkeeping requirements, and builds garage underwriting expertise through training, coaching, and feedback. This is a remote role. Selective offers a competitive base salary and incentive plan eligibility, along with benefits intended to support employees’ health, financial goals, and work-life balance. The pay range is USD $63,000–$81,000 per year, with actual salary dependent on geographic location and other relevant factors.

Requirements

  • Demonstrated effective written and verbal communication skills.
  • Ability to solve problems and make sound decisions.
  • Ability to multitask and manage workflows to meet production and service expectations.
  • Ability to develop and establish effective relationships with internal and external customers and peers.
  • Strong commitment to professional development through on-the-job learning, self-study, and training.
  • Ability to adapt to change as the company advances its strategic vision.
  • Proficiency with supplied desktop tools, including automated underwriting and email systems.
  • Valid state-issued driver’s license in good standing.
  • 1–3 years of experience in garage underwriting support, such as underwriting support, trainee, or underwriter.

Nice To Haves

  • College degree preferred.
  • Completion of basic insurance coursework preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Process and triage submissions, verify completeness and required documents, identify missing information, communicate documentation needs to agents, track open items, and route submissions according to complexity and authority.
  • Apply established underwriting guidelines and eligibility rules to routine garage classes; review operations, locations, vehicle and customer auto handling, and refer out-of-appetite indicators.
  • Perform routine pricing and rating for standard risks under limited authority; validate rating inputs, ensure calculations are accurate, and refer discrepancies or non-standard scenarios with supporting notes.
  • Enter risk data and supporting documents in underwriting systems and accurately document underwriting actions in accordance with audit, peer review, claims, and record-retention standards.
  • Assist with quotes, renewals, endorsements, and routine policy changes in coordination with underwriting and operations teams; maintain suspense and diary controls and document changes appropriately.
  • Provide timely service to agents by acknowledging submissions, sharing status updates, answering basic coverage and process questions, setting turnaround expectations, and following through on escalations.
  • Monitor submission outcomes and recurring patterns affecting conversion; flag issues such as missing information, out-of-appetite exposures, and pricing challenges, and share observations with higher-level underwriters.
  • Collaborate with operations and underwriting peers to resolve processing issues, coordinate priorities and deadlines, and support workflow discussions and continuous improvement.
  • Follow applicable laws, regulations, internal controls, documentation and approval procedures, state-specific requirements, approved forms, and disclosures; promptly escalate potential compliance concerns.
  • Develop garage underwriting knowledge through training, coaching, and feedback, including foundational understanding of garage liability, garage keepers’ exposures, and common risk controls.

Benefits

  • Comprehensive health care plans
  • Retirement savings plan with company match
  • Discounted Employee Stock Purchase Program
  • Tuition assistance and reimbursement programs
  • 20 days of paid time off
  • Incentive plan eligibility at all levels
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service