Director of Claims

Lawley Insurance•Buffalo, NY
•Hybrid

About The Position

Lawley is seeking a Director of Claims to provide consultative and strategic leadership for its growing Claims division. The role oversees claims associates across Personal, Commercial, Captives, and other lines, with an emphasis on client advocacy, proactive risk reduction, and effective team performance. The Director partners with executive leadership and teams across Client Service, Production, Placement, Loss Control, and Workers’ Compensation Claims Management to align departmental priorities with company strategy and client needs. Lawley describes itself as a family-owned insurance broker with a relationship-focused culture and an emphasis on work-life balance. The position is bonus eligible, offers hybrid flexibility, and has business hours of 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. The stated compensation range is $125,000 to $200,000.

Requirements

  • At least 10 years of experience in related insurance property and casualty claims.
  • At least 10 years of demonstrated leadership of people, service, and complex stakeholder relationships.
  • Expert knowledge of Personal and Commercial Lines coverages and claims advocacy, especially General Liability, Property, and Auto.
  • Ability to lead complex claim reviews and carrier escalations.
  • Property/Casualty license covering all lines.
  • Required insurance designations.
  • Bachelor’s degree in a related area or higher.
  • Demonstrated executive leadership and ability to inspire high-performing teams, drive business results, and lead through change.
  • Strong strategic, organizational, and execution skills, including managing complex priorities in a dynamic business environment.
  • Ability to drive initiatives with urgency and precision.
  • Resilient, solutions-oriented approach and ability to lead in a fast-paced, evolving organization.
  • Commitment to exceptional client and colleague experiences and to engagement, accountability, talent development, and inclusion.
  • Exceptional communication and executive presence, with the ability to influence stakeholders, build consensus, and communicate clearly under pressure and during change.

Responsibilities

  • Provide strategic leadership, oversight, and development for Claims associates across all lines of business.
  • Establish departmental goals, objectives, workforce plans, and performance expectations in support of the Claims division’s strategic plan.
  • Develop the Claims team through coaching, training, knowledge sharing, and professional development.
  • Lead substantive claim reviews for large and complex accounts, identify coverage gaps, loss trends, risk exposures, and client needs, and coordinate solutions and follow-up with partner teams.
  • Partner with Loss Control to coordinate client risk mitigation efforts and improve outcomes.
  • Use client feedback, claim experience, and service measures to address recurring issues, improve responsiveness, and strengthen retention and client outcomes.
  • Monitor claims technologies, automation, and industry innovations, and identify opportunities to improve efficiency, capabilities, insights, and experiences.
  • Serve as a liaison among the agency, carriers, attorneys, and clients, and build effective working relationships in local markets.
  • Attend industry events, seminars, and workshops to stay informed about trends, market changes, products, and services.
  • Partner with executive leadership to align departmental priorities with company strategy, growth objectives, and client needs.
  • Serve as a resource to Claims teams and other divisions, departments, and services.
  • Maintain dependable attendance, availability, and punctuality.
  • Participate in leadership programs, workshops, and training; model professionalism and integrity while guiding the team.
  • Support miscellaneous duties and expand responsibilities as requested.

Benefits

  • Competitive health benefits, including medical, dental, and vision coverage.
  • Hybrid flexibility and schedules.
  • Paid parking.
  • Three weeks of paid time off, prorated based on start date, and a generous holiday schedule, available from the first day.
  • Company 401(k) contribution starting on the first day for participants aged 21 and older.
  • Educational support, career development, and growth opportunities.
  • Bonus eligibility.
  • Unlimited volunteer time off opportunities.
  • Work-life balance.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service