Director, Nonprofit Underwriting

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc.,
$131,000 - $185,000Hybrid

About The Position

As the Director of the Nonprofit Division at AmTrust Insurance, you will play a pivotal role in building our second new business team, driving the overall success of the division by overseeing top and bottom-line results, leading product development initiatives, fostering strong agency relationships, and strategically managing profitable growth. This position requires a dynamic and results-oriented individual with a deep understanding of the insurance industry, particularly in the nonprofit sector. This role will require hybrid attendance in one of our AmTrust office locations.

Requirements

  • Proven track record of successfully managing top and bottom-lines results in a leadership capacity.
  • Extensive experience in commercial underwriting, ideally nonprofit/human services accounts
  • Strong knowledge of product development, underwriting principles, and insurance market dynamics.
  • Exceptional interpersonal and communication skills, with the ability to build and maintain strong relationships internally and externally.
  • Strategic thinker with the ability to translate vision into actionable plans.

Responsibilities

  • Develop and implement a comprehensive strategic plan for the Nonprofit Division in alignment with the overall corporate objectives.
  • Provide insightful leadership to the division, guiding the team towards achieving financial targets and sustainable growth.
  • Take ownership of the division’s financial performance, with a focus on achieving and exceeding top and bottom-line results.
  • Develop and monitor key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure and improve financial outcomes.
  • Lead the development and enhancement of insurance products tailored for the nonprofit sector.
  • Stay abreast of industry trends, regulatory changes, and emerging risks to ensure the division’s product offerings remain competitive and relevant.
  • Cultivate and maintain strong relationships with key agency partners to drive business development and retention efforts.
  • Collaborate with agencies to understand market needs and tailor solutions that meeting the unique requirements of nonprofit organizations.
  • Identify and pursue new business opportunities, partnerships, and distribution channels.
  • Build and lead a high-performing team, fostering a culture of collaboration, innovation, and accountability.
  • Provide mentorship, coaching, and professional development opportunities for team members.
  • Ensure that all divisional activities comply with relevant laws, regulations, and industry standards.
  • Collaborate with legal and compliance teams to address regulatory requirements and mitigate compliance risks.

Benefits

  • Medical & Dental Plans
  • Life Insurance, including eligible spouses & children
  • Health Care Flexible Spending
  • Dependent Care
  • 401k Savings Plans
  • Paid Time Off
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service