Claims Examiner I - Commercial Auto PD

Athens AdministratorsLake Mary, FL
Hybrid

About The Position

Athens Administrators has an immediate need for a full-time Claims Examiner I to support our Property & Casualty department. Employees who live less than 26 miles from the Concord, CA, Orange, CA, San Antonio, TX, or Lake Mary, FL offices are required to work once a week in the office. The remaining days can be worked remotely if technical requirements are met, and the employee resides in a state Athens operates in (includes CA, CT, FL, GA, ID, IL, MA, NY, NC, NJ, OH, OK, OR, PA, SC, TN, TX, VA and WV). Athens Program Insurance Services is the centerpiece of P&C claims administration in the specialty programs marketplace. We are totally unique in that we focus only on commercial business specialization across multiple coverage lines. Athens offices are open for business Monday-Friday from 7:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. local time. The schedule for this position is Monday through Friday at 37.5 hours per week. The Claims Examiner I is responsible for the timely investigation, evaluation and determination of settlement or denial of minor to moderate multi-line property & casualty claims. They will be handling claims from inception to closure.

Requirements

  • High School Diploma or equivalent (GED) required for all positions
  • Must possess a license from your domiciled (state you live in or designated home state) state and a minimum of one license in any of the following states: NY, TX or FL
  • Additional State Adjuster License(s) may be required within 180 days
  • Maintain licenses and continuing education requirements in all states.
  • Minimum of three years general claims handling experience
  • Knowledge of property and casualty insurance policies
  • Knowledge of insurance laws, codes, procedures, and liability concepts
  • Proficiency in investigation and resolution of minor to medium level casualty claims
  • Knowledge of general liability insurance principles, codes, procedures, and liability concepts
  • Knowledge of insurance laws, codes, procedures, and liability concepts
  • Ability to evaluate contracts and review policies for coverage
  • Familiarity with labor and material costs to evaluate repair estimates
  • Understanding of premise liability and risk transfer concepts
  • Proficiency in investigation and resolution of minor to medium level BI and PD general liability damage claims
  • Strong negotiation skills and ability to achieve optimal settlement results for clients.
  • Well-developed verbal and written communication skills with strong attention to detail
  • Excellent organizational skills and ability to multi-task
  • Ability to type quickly, accurately and for prolonged periods
  • Proficient in Microsoft Office Suite
  • Reasoning ability, including problem-solving and analytical skills, i.e., proven ability to research and analyze facts, identify issues, and make appropriate recommendations and solutions for resolution
  • Ability to be trustworthy, dependable, and team-oriented for fellow employees and the organization
  • Seeks to include innovative strategies and methods to provide a high level of commitment to service and results
  • Ability to be demonstrate care and concern for fellow team members and clients in a professional and friendly manner
  • Acts with integrity in difficult or challenging situations and is a trustworthy, dependable contributor
  • Athens’ operations involve handling confidential, proprietary, and highly sensitive information, such as health records, client financials, and other personal data. Therefore, maintaining honesty and integrity is essential for all roles within the company.
  • Must be able to reliably commute to meetings and events as required by this position

Nice To Haves

  • AA/AS or BA/BS preferred but not required
  • Familiarity with construction methods and building components preferred

Responsibilities

  • Knowledge in the following areas: 1) claims handling concepts, practices and techniques, to include but not limited to coverage issues, and product line knowledge, 2) functional knowledge of law and insurance regulations in various jurisdictions, 3) demonstrated advanced verbal and written communications skills, 4) demonstrated analytical, decision making and negotiation skills.
  • Investigate coverage, including evaluate insurance coverage problems and/or disputes
  • Investigate, evaluate, and determine settlement value or denial of liability for all claims
  • Develop a measure of damage for each loss, establish and maintain appropriate reserves
  • Document and manage claims (i.e.: record statements, update diaries, write reports) from inception to closure
  • Ensure appropriateness of all payments
  • Negotiate settlement of claim within individual authority ($15,000 unless otherwise noted)
  • Maintain and update action plans for each claim.
  • May assign and coordinate with vendors, legal counsel, appraisers, or experts as necessary
  • Facilitate between claimants, clients, brokers, and attorneys in resolution of liability claims
  • Exchange information with clients, claimants, insurance brokers, inspectors, producers, and account managers
  • Provide customer service and support to insureds and claimants
  • Assist in training of new employees
  • Attend meetings and educational seminars for professional development
  • Maintain required licenses

Benefits

  • Medical
  • Vision
  • Dental
  • Life and AD&D
  • Long Term Care
  • Critical Care
  • Accidental
  • Hospital Indemnity
  • HSA & FSA options
  • 401k (and Roth)
  • Company-Paid STD & LTD
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service