Claim Supervisor

A.I.M. Mutual Insurance Companies•Burlington, MA
•$100,000 - $108,000•Onsite

About The Position

The Claim Supervisor directs, organizes, and coordinates the ongoing activities of assigned staff and territory to ensure production, quality, and service meet or exceed company standards and goals. The role facilitates claims handling to meet unit, department, and organizational goals, including the prompt and fair handling of assigned claims. Under limited supervision and with some discretion, the Claim Supervisor makes decisions within the scope of the position. The role has a direct impact on revenue and requires advanced concentration to complete considerably complex job functions. The Claim Supervisor manages assigned employees and is responsible for their performance management, participating in hiring when necessary. The position is full-time, with a typical 35-hour work week, Monday through Friday, 8:00 AM to 4:00 PM. The work takes place in a professional office environment, with occasional exposure to light or moderate noise. Occasional local travel during the business day may be required. The company may assign additional related or unrelated duties from time to time. Associated Insurance Management, LLC complies with the ADA and state disability laws and does not discriminate against qualified individuals with disabilities in any phase of employment.

Requirements

  • At least 10 years of claims adjusting experience, with an emphasis on workers’ compensation.
  • Experience managing and/or supervising others, preferably in claims adjusting.
  • Exceptional writing and communication skills.
  • In-depth knowledge of company service expectations and the ability to convey those expectations to customers.
  • Ability to organize and prioritize unit production.

Nice To Haves

  • Bachelor’s degree preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Provide a workers’ compensation experience that offers peace of mind through empathetic listening, compassionate action, doing the right thing, and collaboration.
  • Cultivate a positive work environment and relationships through interactions with brokers, policyholders, customers, vendors, coworkers, and management.
  • Manage team activity by assigning claims, reviewing diaries and claim activity, authorizing payments, and ensuring claims are handled in accordance with company, state, and industry requirements.
  • Review reserve and settlement requests and approve authority appropriate to team members’ experience and capability; oversee team reserves and manage daily payments on hold.
  • Manage claims negotiations based on adjuster experience and case complexity; assist with cases beyond adjuster authority or experience and refer matters above supervisor authority to the Claim Manager.
  • Communicate with policyholders, brokers, and defense counsel as needed.
  • Oversee team litigation and pursue expedient, economic, and equitable settlements of meritorious claims while contesting and defending claims without merit.
  • Issue regular, comprehensive production reports and ensure claims are properly documented from first report through disposition through diary review.
  • Communicate unit, department, and organizational expectations through regularly scheduled team meetings, as directed by Claim Managers and/or the Director of Claims.
  • Direct, manage, coach, and develop assigned staff; provide timely performance reviews based on company service standards and communicate organizational expectations.
  • Review work product and direct vendors, including defense attorneys, nurse case managers, and private investigators; monitor team expenses to promote sound judgment and avoid unnecessary costs.
  • Provide claim reviews and other on-site services as needed as part of a claim or operations service team.
  • Regularly update team member schedules in Burlington on the Office Calendar in Outlook.
  • Follow and remain current on company compliance and security policies and procedures.
  • Work with other departments to meet company standards.
  • Participate in hiring when necessary and manage the performance of assigned employees.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service