Claim Examiner I

AmTrust Financial Services, Inc.•Maitland, FL
•Hybrid

About The Position

The Claim Examiner I handles assigned Workers' Compensation claims, conducting prompt and independent claim reviews through research, evaluation, investigation, negotiation, and interaction with insureds and claimants. The role is often assigned mid-size or mid-complexity claims and is expected to uphold AmTrust’s mission, vision, values, and Claims organization standards. This position works four days in the office and one day remotely from the Maitland, Florida office. Some positions require travel.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree or equivalent experience.
  • At least 3 years of claims handling experience.
  • State licensure as required.
  • Demonstrated proficiency with Microsoft Office suites.
  • Demonstrated investigation, evaluation, and negotiation skills.
  • Strong knowledge of insurance theory and practices.

Nice To Haves

  • At least 2 years of specific Workers’ Compensation experience preferred.

Responsibilities

  • Investigate claims and coverage by making timely, appropriate contact with involved or interested parties, including insureds or employer representatives, claimants or injured workers, witnesses, and producers.
  • Analyze whether coverage applies under the policy or statutes; review coverage issues with a supervisor as needed and draft positions when required.
  • Establish and adjust reserves based on the most likely claim outcome, case facts, company standards, and experience.
  • Partner with internal or assigned legal counsel on claims as needed, building strong working relationships in accordance with company principles and standards.
  • Negotiate litigated claims effectively, building trust with other parties and demonstrating good timing.
  • Coordinate with internal Managed Care and Medical resources, as applicable, to support appropriate treatment plans and accurate billing.
  • Obtain medical records and reports, police, ambulance, and agency reports, photographs, and measurements as applicable.
  • Apply critical thinking and decision-making skills to gather, assess, analyze, question, verify, interpret, and understand key or root issues.
  • Write clearly, succinctly, and factually in claims files and other communications.
  • Learn technical materials and learn from mistakes.
  • Manage time and diary entries effectively and efficiently, prioritizing work in a fast-paced environment.
  • Establish and maintain effective customer relationships and earn customers’ respect and trust.
  • Perform other functional duties as requested or required.

Benefits

  • Medical plans
  • Dental plans
  • Life insurance, including coverage for eligible spouses and children
  • Health Care Flexible Spending
  • Dependent Care
  • 401(k) Savings Plans
  • Paid Time Off
  • Competitive compensation package
  • Career advancement opportunities
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service