Case Manager I

Preparing for the Future•Indianapolis, IN
•Hybrid

About The Position

The Case Manager I supports the smooth and efficient progression of cases through the New Business and Underwriting processes. This foundational case-management role focuses on transactional tasks and timely, accurate case handling, helping maintain streamlined operations and a positive customer experience throughout the New Business application process. The position works in coordination with other team members and is expected to meet established performance metrics for case-processing speed, communication effectiveness, and customer satisfaction. The selected candidate is expected to work in a hybrid arrangement in Indianapolis, Indiana, and may be required to return to the Indiana office as business needs dictate or for team-building and collaboration. OneAmerica Financial does not have offices in New York, and associates may not work remotely from New York.

Requirements

  • High school diploma required.
  • One to two years of customer service experience required.
  • Strong self-accountability and attention to detail.
  • Ability to perform effectively in a fast-paced, high-volume customer service environment.
  • Professional written and verbal communication skills.
  • Ability to collaborate with internal stakeholders.
  • Ability to meet or exceed established performance metrics.
  • Proficiency with Microsoft Office products.

Nice To Haves

  • College degree or equivalent work experience preferred; relevant experience may be in insurance, operations, call center, or financial services.

Responsibilities

  • Handle key transactional items within Case Manager queues and other tools.
  • Order medical underwriting requirements through internal systems and third-party vendors.
  • Review and update vendor-related sites.
  • Make outbound calls and send emails to external insurance carriers to determine the status of funds transfers.
  • Document obtained information clearly and concisely in the field-facing system.
  • Manage day-to-day case tasks and complete actions needed for timely and accurate case progression in alignment with New Business and Underwriting processes.
  • Meet or exceed performance metrics for case-processing speed, communication effectiveness, and customer satisfaction.

Benefits

  • Medical and prescription coverage
  • Dental insurance
  • Vision insurance
  • Health Savings Account and Flexible Spending Accounts
  • Paid time off
  • Ten weeks of 100% paid parental leave after 12 months of employment
  • 401(k) plan with company match
  • Pension plan
  • Company-paid life and disability insurance
  • Wellness Program
  • Company-paid employee assistance program
  • Clinic access, subject to location
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service