Broker/ Senior Broker (Hybrid - NY)

NFPKingston, NY
Hybrid

About The Position

Responsible for broking new and renewal business, handling all aspects of the placements from initial market selection through policy delivery to client. The Broker/ Senior Broker focuses on the largest and most complex placements, while serving in a leadership capacity to mentor and develop staff while cultivating strong insurer and insurer-client-broker relationships. This is a full-time, hybrid position based out of any of the following office locations: New York City, Albany, Rochester, Amherst, White Plains (NY), or Boston, MA. To support hybrid/remote work, candidates must have access to a reliable, confidential, and interruption-free workspace, along with a stable high-speed internet connection.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree or equivalent required
  • Minimum seven years insurance experience
  • P&C License required or obtained within 90 days of employment
  • Excellent leadership and portfolio management skills
  • Excellent written and verbal communication skills
  • Sound understanding of broker operating fundamentals and financials
  • Excellent negotiation skills – ability to adjust approach to effectively drive optimal outcomes depending on different personalities
  • Excellent organizational skills with ability to adjust to changing workload, work complexity and priorities
  • Ability to work collaboratively as a key team member and mentor to junior team members
  • Self-motivated and determined with positive attitude and sense of urgency
  • Strong attention to detail with strong analytical skills, both quantitative and qualitative
  • Proven technical competency and creativity demonstrating excellence in developing and delivering innovative property and casualty solutions
  • Confident, poised and interactive - when client-facing communicates effectively, demonstrates emotional intelligence, and understands how to tailor responses in a variety of dynamic situations
  • Proficient in Microsoft Office Suite

Nice To Haves

  • Team leadership experience a plus
  • Experience with Epic (agency management system) a plus
  • Advanced industry designation(s) (e.g. CPCU, CIC, ARM) preferred

Responsibilities

  • Proactively coordinate and manage broking around the renewal cycle in accordance to NFP’s service model standards and timelines
  • Define success and direct broking activity, individually and amongst the team, to achieve the optimal outcome for the client/prospect; ensure a go-to-market strategy is in place for each broking engagement
  • Demonstrate exceptional negotiation skills – possess an awareness of different personality types with the ability to adjust approach to effectively drive the optimal outcome; capable of interacting with audiences of various seniority within client, carrier, wholesale and specialty organizations; effectively manage difficult scenarios and collaborate with Broking Team Leader on alternatives and solutions
  • Execute client/prospect placements demonstrating an unmistakable command of the risk to be placed and a clear focus on driving the optimal outcome in both financial and non-financial terms
  • Collaborate with account management team and client to ensure complete and timely submissions, respond to carrier queries, compile and analyze carrier quote proposals, and present clients with a clear summary of the marketing process and a proposal with recommendations
  • Develop creative solutions to effectively address difficult placement scenarios; own the process and drive outcomes to enhance customer satisfaction around key deliverables
  • Lead team members in preparation of proposal presentations for existing and prospective clients
  • Support team members in responding to client queries and concerns to resolve issues promptly
  • Present proposals to producers and account management teams and leads client meetings
  • Oversee the development of sales documents, presentations, stewardship reports, and RFP responses for prospective clients
  • Prepare detailed and complex coverage and policy comparisons, diagnostics, consolidated coverage/policy analyses, letters, and reports under the direction of the Broking Team Leader
  • Oversee the review of binders and policies to ensure terms and conditions are accurately reflected
  • Provide leadership and demonstrate an ability to effectively mentor, support and develop team members
  • Develop strong, productive, trustful and resilient relationships with carrier and wholesale partners and their staff and NFP local office teams
  • Provide oversight and ensure the accuracy of client and policy information in NFP’s Epic agency management system
  • Drive and ensure the effective deployment of data and analytics to provide meaningful program insight for clients and the broking team
  • Develop and ensure the deployment of differentiated client services through a thoughtful and sound execution of the client stewardship process that enhances the quality of client relationships
  • Ensure technology resources are showcased and appropriately introduced to defined customers
  • Provide oversight ensuring client, broking and brokerage data files are maintained in a timely, complete and organized fashion
  • Lead by example in executing on NFP’s broking strategies, including strategic carriers, panels, and preferred wholesaler utilization
  • Develop and maintain thorough knowledge of insurance marketplace, products and services
  • Demonstrate a strong understanding of a variety of P&C risk financing strategies
  • Demonstrate an understanding of actuarial analysis and the utilization of its concepts
  • Lead and support the all portfolio management objectives under the direction of the Broking Team Leader

Benefits

  • Competitive salary
  • PTO & paid holidays
  • 401(k) with match
  • Exclusive discount programs
  • Health & wellness programs
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service