Assistant Vice President, Claims

Great American Insurance Group•Cincinnati, OH

1d•Onsite

About The Position

The Assistant Vice President of Claims provides leadership and strategic oversight for Mid‑Continent Group’s most complex and highest exposure casualty claims. This role leads a team of experienced claims professionals handling sophisticated General Liability, Commercial Auto, Construction Injury, and Pollution/Tank Owner Liability losses. Building on a stable and well‑established foundation, the Assistant Vice President is responsible for advancing claim strategy, strengthening litigation management, and continuing the elevation of team performance. The role emphasizes disciplined evaluation, early identification of value‑driving facts and exposures, and proactive management of high‑stakes litigated matters to support consistent, defensible outcomes. The Assistant Vice President operates with significant autonomy and accountability, balancing hands‑on technical engagement in critical situations with leadership that enables experienced professionals to perform at a high level. This position requires strong technical judgment, sound decision‑making, and the ability to partner effectively across the enterprise while guiding the team through ongoing operational and systems transitions.

Requirements

Extensive experience handling complex, high‑exposure casualty matters, gained through senior insurance carrier claims leadership and/or substantial litigation practice involving serious bodily injury and liability disputes.
Demonstrated success managing highly litigated matters with significant severity, complexity, and visibility, including responsibility for strategy, evaluation, and resolution.
Proven leadership experience guiding experienced professionals, with accountability for outcomes, strategy, and performance.
Advanced technical judgment in liability analysis, damages evaluation, litigation strategy, negotiation, and risk assessment.
Ability to operate effectively in ambiguous, high‑stakes situations requiring disciplined analysis, sound judgment, and timely decision‑making.

Responsibilities

Provide leadership and strategic direction for a team of approximately 15 professionals managing the organization’s most complex and highest exposure casualty claims.
Establish and reinforce disciplined claim and litigation strategies, with particular focus on early identification of value‑driving facts, exposures, venues, and damages.
Engage selectively in high‑exposure and critical litigated matters to ensure appropriate investigation, reserving discipline, and defensible outcomes, intervening to prevent adverse or unexpected results when necessary.
Direct and oversee litigation management, maintaining close engagement with defense counsel to ensure alignment on strategy, preparation, budgeting, and resolution planning.
Hold defense counsel accountable for performance, efficiency, and results, including participation in panel selection and ongoing evaluation.
Lead and develop a seasoned claims team through clear expectations, effective coaching, and direct, meaningful performance management.
Advance consistency, planning, and execution across the team while guiding professionals through operational and systems transitions, including ClaimCenter implementation.
Partner with senior Claims leadership and enterprise stakeholders to support aligned strategies, informed decision‑making, and effective communication on significant exposures.