Workers' Compensation Claim Specialist

Hastings Insurance Company•Hastings, MI
•Remote

About The Position

Hastings Insurance is seeking an experienced Workers' Compensation Claim Specialist to investigate, evaluate, and resolve complex Workers' Compensation claims, including litigated matters. The specialist independently manages a high-complexity caseload from initial investigation through resolution or settlement, applying technical knowledge and sound judgment to achieve fair and timely outcomes and provide exceptional service to insureds, claimants, and other stakeholders. The role also serves as a technical resource and mentor to other claim professionals, assists with departmental training and special projects, and may provide guidance in the Claim Supervisor's absence when requested. This is a full-time, salaried position working Monday through Friday, generally 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Flexible work arrangements are available for candidates residing in Ohio, Indiana, Illinois, or Wisconsin. Employees residing outside Michigan work remotely, with periodic travel to headquarters as required.

Requirements

  • At least five years of Workers' Compensation claims experience, including the ability to independently manage complex claims.
  • Claims handling experience in at least one of the company's Workers' Compensation coverage states: Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, or Wisconsin.
  • Strong knowledge of Workers' Compensation claims practices, including compensability, investigation, reserving, negotiation, and claim resolution.
  • Excellent verbal and written communication skills and the ability to interact professionally and effectively with diverse stakeholders.
  • Strong critical-thinking, analytical, and decision-making skills, including sound judgment with minimal supervision.
  • Demonstrated negotiation and conflict-management skills, including the ability to navigate challenging situations while maintaining productive relationships.
  • Excellent customer service, organizational, time-management, and prioritization skills.
  • Ability to work effectively independently and collaboratively within a team environment.
  • Adaptability to changing assignments, priorities, regulations, and business needs.
  • Proficiency with Microsoft Office applications, including Word and Excel.
  • Obtain and maintain applicable state adjuster licenses and continuing education requirements, as needed.

Nice To Haves

  • Bachelor's degree, an insurance industry designation, or active pursuit of a professional designation.
  • Ten years of progressively responsible claims experience.

Responsibilities

  • Independently manage complex Workers' Compensation claims, including litigated matters, from initial investigation through resolution or settlement.
  • Investigate claims; evaluate coverage, compensability, and exposure; and negotiate fair and equitable settlements in accordance with contractual obligations, regulations, and company guidelines.
  • Establish and maintain accurate case reserves based on anticipated claim costs, potential settlements, litigation, and other relevant factors.
  • Manage litigated claims by collaborating with legal counsel, overseeing litigation strategies, and controlling related legal expenses.
  • Communicate professionally and productively with insureds, agents, claimants, attorneys, vendors, and other stakeholders throughout the claims process.
  • Identify and pursue salvage and subrogation opportunities and use loss and expense management programs to minimize claim costs.
  • Coordinate and monitor outside vendors, service providers, and experts to ensure services are high-quality, necessary, and cost-effective.
  • Document claim activities, decisions, and resolutions accurately and thoroughly in the company's claim management system.
  • Recognize potential indicators of fraud and refer appropriate matters to the Special Investigations Unit.
  • Collaborate with internal business partners, including Loss Control, Underwriting, and Sales, to coordinate claim information and support effective outcomes.
  • Serve as a technical resource and mentor to other claim professionals, providing guidance on coverage, reserving, exposure evaluation, settlement strategies, and complex claims.
  • Assist with departmental training, provide guidance in the Claim Supervisor's absence when requested, and participate in special projects and committees.
  • Participate in legal proceedings, including depositions, hearings, or trials, as necessary.
  • Obtain and maintain applicable state adjuster licenses and continuing education requirements, as needed.

Benefits

  • 401(k) with company matching contributions
  • Generous paid time off
  • Tuition and professional development assistance
  • Company performance-based incentive compensation opportunities
  • Competitive pay and benefits
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service