Senior Product Manager, Faith & Strategy

Pushpay•Colorado Springs, CO
•$106,000 - $137,000•Hybrid

About The Position

Pushpay is seeking a Senior Product Manager to improve the value churches receive from its core product portfolio. The role takes ownership of high-impact problems across product areas, rapidly builds understanding of unfamiliar workflows, and delivers work from discovery through launch and adoption. It combines product leadership with deep knowledge of church operations, keeping churches’ needs central while influencing teams across the portfolio without direct authority. The Senior Product Manager uses customer research and portfolio signals—including adoption, retention, NPS, and CSat—to identify opportunities, make recommendations, and measure outcomes. The role also models strong product practices, coaches other PMs, collaborates with Engineering and UX, and helps Sales, Customer Success, and Product Marketing communicate product value. AI features should reduce administrative effort while preserving pastoral judgment, relationships, privacy, and trust. The position may be hybrid in the Colorado Springs area (three days in office and two remote) or remote from an approved state. The role requires at least five years of end-to-end B2B SaaS product management experience and fluency in church operations, whether gained through church staff or volunteer leadership or through work on church or ministry software. Success is measured by shipped and adopted product, improved adoption, retention and satisfaction, insight that changes decisions, time saved for church staff, and stronger PM practices.

Requirements

  • At least 5 years of experience owning B2B SaaS products end to end, from discovery through adoption, with quantifiable and defensible outcomes.
  • A record of shipping products that customers adopt and measuring and owning the results, including misses.
  • Church operations fluency gained through church staff or volunteer leadership, or product work on church or ministry software.
  • Understanding of how churches staff, organize volunteers, communicate, and steward resources.
  • A personal connection to or deep respect for the Church.
  • Ability to become fluent in new domains quickly and respond effectively when priorities shift.
  • Ability to influence outcomes across teams without direct authority, using expertise and trust.
  • Ability to use adoption and satisfaction data to guide decisions and recognize when customer conversations are needed to interpret data.
  • Knowledge of AI capabilities and limitations in ministry contexts, including defining requirements for LLM-based features and recognizing when human judgment is more appropriate than automation.
  • Comfort with APIs and integrations and understanding of the importance of being the source of truth for church data.
  • Clear communication, a well-supported point of view, and willingness to adapt based on evidence.

Nice To Haves

  • Experience with complex workflows or financial data.

Responsibilities

  • Own high-priority problems and opportunities across the product portfolio, from discovery through launch and adoption.
  • Ramp quickly in new workflow areas, form a point of view, and deliver products to customers.
  • Use knowledge of church operations and targeted discovery with pastors, administrators, and volunteer leaders to inform product decisions.
  • Monitor adoption, retention, NPS, and CSat; identify trends, make recommendations, and help teams act on them.
  • Model strong product management practices, including clear problem statements, outcome-based success measures, and honest retrospectives.
  • Coach other product managers and share effective practices.
  • Collaborate across product domains, Engineering, and UX to ensure church needs are understood, prioritized, and delivered.
  • Build trust and business cases, influence teams without direct authority, and escalate when appropriate.
  • Identify ways AI can reduce friction or surface insight, while maintaining human oversight and protecting church privacy and trust.
  • Support Sales, Customer Success, and Product Marketing in communicating Pushpay’s value to pastors and church administrators.
  • Represent the product at key church conferences and customer events.
  • Define measurable outcomes and report results honestly, including product adoption, retention, satisfaction, time savings, and PM craft improvements.

Benefits

  • 100% employer-paid premiums for the employee’s Medical HDHP plan, Dental, and Vision.
  • 70% employer-paid premiums for the employee’s Medical PPO plan and for dependents’ Medical, Dental, and Vision.
  • 401(k) match.
  • 12 paid company holidays.
  • 2 paid Volunteer Time Off days.
  • 20 days of PTO to start, increasing with tenure and seniority.
  • Paid parental and adoption leave.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service