Senior Investigator

Highmark Health•PA, Working at Home - Pennsylvania, PA
•$72,700 - $116,600•Onsite

About The Position

The Senior Investigator develops and maintains Highmark’s anti-fraud program, including delivering fraud training and filing fraud plans and reports. The role investigates alleged fraud, waste, and abuse involving providers, members, facilities, pharmacies, groups, and employees of Highmark and its subsidiaries. Work includes interviews, onsite or offsite investigative activities, data analysis, audits, case referrals, and coordinating recovery or savings of funds. The investigator may testify in court, prepare cases for law enforcement referral, and work with law enforcement and regulatory agencies through case closure. The position also serves as a subject matter expert, provides guidance and mentoring to investigators, and may lead departmental special projects. It performs proactive and investigative audits, including contract, commission, surveillance, workers’ compensation, independent medical examination, and Office of Foreign Asset Control reviews. The role is office-based and may involve occasional travel to work sites. It requires compliance with company policies, applicable laws, HIPAA, and information-security requirements.

Requirements

  • Bachelor’s degree in Accounting, Finance, Business Administration, Nursing, IT, or a related field; alternatively, six years of related and progressive experience may substitute for the degree.
  • Five years of experience in the health insurance industry and/or healthcare fraud investigations.
  • One year of experience leading projects of varying size and complexity.
  • Knowledge of provider facility payment methodology, claims processing systems, and coding and billing.
  • Understanding of the technical and financial aspects of the health insurance industry.
  • Strong personal computer skills and ability to use fraud and abuse data-mining tools.
  • Excellent communication skills and attention to detail.
  • Strong written and oral communication skills.
  • Strong relationship-building skills.
  • Client-focused approach and strong business acumen.
  • Ability to work independently and as part of a team under pressure.
  • Ability to think strategically and act proactively to build trust and confidence with business units.
  • Innovative problem-solving capabilities.

Nice To Haves

  • Master’s degree in Fraud, Forensic Accounting, Business, or a related field.
  • Three years of financial analysis experience in an acute care hospital or health insurance setting.
  • Three years of experience in professional billing, facility Patient Financial Services, HIM, Internal Audit, Professional/Facility Reimbursement, or Provider Contracting.
  • Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE).
  • Certified Professional Coder (CPC).
  • Certified Outpatient Coder (COC).
  • Accredited Healthcare Fraud Investigator (AHFI).

Responsibilities

  • Investigate potential and existing provider and member fraud, waste, and abuse, identifying parties involved by reviewing inquiries and complaints.
  • Conduct interviews with providers, members, and other individuals as needed for investigations or special projects.
  • Determine the scope of allegations or projects by gathering relevant information, statistics, policies, procedures, licensure information, agreements, and contracts.
  • Coordinate data extracts and assess internal and external databases.
  • Take action to prevent further improper payments and refer cases to credentialing or medical review committees, law enforcement, and regulatory agencies.
  • Develop and maintain the annual anti-fraud program, facilitate fraud training and awareness activities, file annual fraud plans and reports according to state regulations, and update information on changes in insurance laws.
  • Serve as a subject matter expert for investigators, provide guidance, and train or mentor team members; potentially lead departmental special projects.
  • Complete field investigative work required to resolve alleged fraud, waste, and abuse cases or special projects.
  • Provide advisory support to law enforcement and regulatory agencies and to credentialing or medical review committees.
  • Deliver audit results, negotiate overpayments, coordinate recovery or savings of misappropriated funds, and work with Finance to ensure appropriate financial-statement recording.
  • Conduct proactive and investigative audits for internal audit and regulatory compliance, including contract, commissions, surveillance, workers’ compensation, and IME audits.
  • Complete Office of Foreign Asset Control reviews to help ensure payments are not issued to unauthorized parties.
  • Testify in court and prepare cases for referral to federal, state, and local law enforcement entities, working with agencies through case closure.
  • Perform other duties as assigned or requested.
© 2026 Teal Labs, Inc
Privacy PolicyTerms of Service